The Supreme Court directs Punjab and Haryana to make good the electricity that Himachal Pradesh did not receive for decades from the Bhakra-Nangal and Beas hydro-electric projects. The arrears are fixed at 13,066 million units of power. They are to be paid in kind, that is in electricity and not in money, over 20 years.

The judgment was delivered on 6 November 2026 by a bench of Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana. The Chief Justice wrote it. The case is State of Himachal Pradesh versus Union of India and others, Original Suit No. 2 of 1996.

What the dispute was about

The two projects were built substantially on land that is now part of Himachal Pradesh. The judgment records that the Bhakra-Nangal Project required the submergence of approximately 27,869 acres of the former State of Bilaspur, and the Beas Project over 65,050 acres in Kangra district. The power, however, was enjoyed principally by the undivided State of Punjab and, after 1966, by Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan and Chandigarh.

Punjab was reorganised with effect from 1 November 1966, and part of its territory and population was transferred to Himachal Pradesh. Section 78 of the Punjab Reorganisation Act, 1966 provided that rights and liabilities in the two projects would be divided among the successor States by agreement or, failing that, by an order of the Central Government. No final division was made, and power went on being shared on an ad hoc, or stopgap, basis.

Himachal Pradesh filed the suit in 1996 under Article 131 of the Constitution, invoking the Supreme Court's original jurisdiction, which means the Court hears the case itself as the first court.

What was already settled in 2011

On 27 September 2011 the Court decreed the suit in part. A decree is the formal order that decides a suit. It held Himachal Pradesh entitled to 7.19% of the power attributable to undivided Punjab, the figure the State had claimed on the basis of the share of Punjab's population transferred to it. The claim to 12% free power was not accepted.

The Union of India was told to work out what was due. In an affidavit filed on 5 July 2013 it put the shortfall up to October 2011 at 13,066 million units. Himachal Pradesh accepted the figure, while Punjab and Haryana disputed it. Repeated attempts at a settlement through the Attorney General for India did not succeed.

What the Court decided

The Court now adopts a framework proposed by the Attorney General and issues these directions:

  • The energy arrears due to Himachal Pradesh are taken at 13,066 million units.
  • The State's liability for its 7.19% share of the capital cost of the projects, meaning the cost of building them, is assessed at Rs 420.77 crores: Rs 249.23 crores attributable to Punjab and Rs 171.55 crores to Haryana.
  • That liability is set off against the arrears. Energy is valued at Rs 3.85 per unit for this purpose, which removes approximately 1,093 million units.
  • The balance of approximately 11,973 million units is to be supplied by Punjab and Haryana at approximately 598 million units a year over 20 lean seasons, the period from October to March.
  • The two States share the supply in the ratio of 58:42 for the Bhakra-Nangal Project and 60:40 for the Beas Projects.
  • Himachal Pradesh pays the charges fixed by the Bhakra Beas Management Board for the year in which each instalment of energy is received.
"The settlement shall accordingly be implemented on a cashless basis"

The Attorney General had suggested supply over 15 years. The Court extends this to 20 years as a concession to the defendant States, having regard to the total quantity of arrears.

Why Punjab's objections failed

Himachal Pradesh and Haryana agreed to the proposal in principle. Punjab raised three objections. It said a separate daily supply of 1.2 lakh units to Himachal Pradesh should reduce the arrears to 11,094 million units. It said the capital cost should be converted into energy at the current operation and maintenance rate of 79 paise per unit. And it asked for 30 years to supply the power.

The Court is not persuaded by any of these points. It finds them vague and an attempt to relitigate issues settled by the 2011 decree. The daily supply, it says, has already been considered and accounted for in the capital cost liability worked out in the Union's framework.

On the conversion rate, the Court sees an attempt to inflate Himachal Pradesh's liability and so reduce what it is owed. It rejects the approach because "the arrears relate to an earlier period and cannot be computed at a rate that prevails today". On the 30 year period, it notes that Punjab gave no reason other than that an earlier submission of the Union had mentioned it.

The Court also makes clear that it is not reopening the 2011 decision. The present exercise, it says, is in the nature of execution proceedings, the stage at which a decree already passed is carried out.

How the case ends

The Court records its appreciation of the Attorney General's efforts in attempting mediation and framing the settlement. It tells all the parties that "the directions issued by this Court are binding and are required to be acted upon without reservation".

The suit stands disposed of, and pending applications are disposed of in the same terms.