The Supreme Court holds that its ruling of 11 March 2026 on the creamy layer among the Other Backward Classes (OBC) does not reopen selections or appointments completed before that date, but will govern the allocation of services to OBC candidates selected through the Civil Services Examination, 2025. Those placed in the creamy layer are not eligible for the benefit of reservation.

The order was passed on 6 November 2026 by a bench of Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice R. Mahadevan in Union of India v. Rohith Nathan and Another (MA 3313-3315/2026 in C.A. No. 2827-2829/2018). The Court declines to give the Union government two years to frame a policy, and extends the time to comply with the March judgment by two months.

What the dispute was about

The case concerns candidates who cleared the Civil Services Examinations and whose parents worked in Public Sector Undertakings (PSUs). Because the equivalence of PSU posts with Government posts had not been formally determined, the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) applied an income and wealth test under a government instruction dated 8 September 1993, called the 1993 OM, read with a clarificatory letter dated 14 October 2004.

After assessing the parents' income for the preceding three financial years, the DoPT placed the candidates in the creamy layer. The candidates succeeded before the Central Administrative Tribunal, and the High Courts of Madras, Delhi and Kerala dismissed the government's petitions.

By its judgment of 11 March 2026, the Supreme Court dismissed the Union's civil appeals. It directed the government to consider the claims of the respondent candidates and of the intervenors, other candidates who had sought to join the case, on the principles it laid down, within six months.

What the Union asked for

The Union then filed miscellaneous applications, which are requests made in a case that has already been decided. It asked the Court to direct that the March judgment would not apply retrospectively, that is, to selections, appointments and admissions already completed. It also sought two years to establish the equivalence of posts, and permission to finalise service allocation for the 2025 examination on the principles it applied before 11 March 2026.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta submitted that the final result of the 2025 examination had been declared on 6 March 2026, five days before the judgment. He pointed to the potential impact on more than 6.69 lakh reserved vacancies, including 3.70 lakh OBC vacancies, filled over the preceding ten years. Relying on Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, he asked that the judgment be directed to operate prospectively, meaning only for the future.

Counsel for the candidates opposed the applications as an attempt to seek a rehearing. One counsel said the Union had not explained a 166-day delay in filing.

What the Court decided

The Court entertains the applications only to clarify the scope and timing of the directions already given. Its reading of the 1993 OM and the 2004 letter, its rejection of mechanical exclusion based on salary income, and the relief given to the successful candidates are not open to reconsideration, it says.

The Court draws a line between the relief granted and the legal principle declared. The relief was confined to the parties before it, including the intervenors. The interpretation it laid down is, however, a binding precedent under Article 141 of the Constitution.

The Court says the Union proceeded on an erroneous assumption that it had to carry out a retrospective exercise. The six-month period was meant only for the respondent candidates and intervenors. No further time is needed for an

"exercise that was not directed by this Court in the first place."

The directions

  • The respondent candidates fall within the non-creamy layer of the OBC category. They are entitled to reservation, with consequential placement and allotment of posts in the selection processes in which they took part.
  • This benefit shall not, by itself, harm the seniority of any other person or reopen selections or appointments already concluded.
  • The Government may accommodate the parties before the Court who otherwise fulfil the eligibility conditions. The Court notes the DoPT's assurance on creating supernumerary posts, meaning additional posts, for this purpose.
  • The ruling shall not, by itself, be a ground for reopening selections or appointments concluded before 11 March 2026. Pending claims of persons who say they are similarly placed may be considered on their own merits by the forum concerned, which may take the Court's interpretation into consideration.
  • All selections, appointments and allotments against roster points made after 11 March 2026, so far as they concern reservation and the exclusion of the creamy layer, shall be governed by the 1993 OM as interpreted by the Court.
  • The Court sets no timeline for establishing equivalence between posts or consulting stakeholders, since these matters fall within the "domain of the executive and the legislature."

Effect on the 2025 examination

On the Civil Services Examination, 2025, the Court notes that although the result was declared on 6 March 2026, the allocation of services has not yet been finalised. It finds "no convincing or reasonable" justification for deferring the implementation of the March judgment.

The creamy layer principle, as interpreted in that judgment, shall therefore govern that allocation. The miscellaneous applications stand disposed of, and the time for compliance with the judgment is extended by two months from 6 November 2026.