The Supreme Court of India holds that arbitrators cannot rewrite the contract they are asked to enforce. It declines to restore an arbitral award that had ordered five landowners in Thane to sell their share in family land to a builder. An arbitral award is the decision of arbitrators, private judges chosen by the parties in place of a court. The Court also orders the landowners to return the money the builder paid them, with interest.
The judgment was delivered on 29 October 2026 by Justice Sanjay Kumar, sitting with Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva, in Shreeram Builders versus Upendra Kantilal Thanawala and others, Civil Appeal Nos. 9817-9818 of 2024.
What the dispute was about
The case arises from a document titled Agreement for Development, dated 06.08.2003, between five members of the Thanawala family and the firm Shreeram Builders and its partners. It concerned the family members' 2/9th undivided share in three adjoining parcels of land in Village Panchpakhadi, Thane.
The price was fixed at ₹915 per square foot of Floor Space Index, or FSI, the building area permitted on the land. The FSI was estimated at 25,000 square feet, giving a total of ₹2,28,75,000, most of it payable in instalments.
The landowners ended the agreement by a legal notice dated 09.04.2008. The dispute went to a tribunal of three arbitrators.
By a majority award dated 10.12.2011, two arbitrators held the termination illegal. They granted the builder specific performance, meaning an order that the contract be carried out, and directed the landowners to execute a sale deed once the builder deposited ₹10,91,30,164. The third arbitrator dissented.
The Principal District Judge, Thane, upheld the majority award. On appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, the Bombay High Court set it aside by judgment dated 05.03.2024. The builder then came to the Supreme Court.
What the Court decided
The Court finds no grounds to uphold the majority award. It agrees with the High Court that the award violated Section 28(3) of the Act, which requires an arbitral tribunal to decide by taking into account the terms of the contract. The award is tested under Section 34 of the Act, the provision that sets out when a court may set aside an award.
The Court says it was not essential to label the document as a development agreement or an agreement to sell. What mattered were its terms, which laid down the order in which each side had to perform.
The Court's reasons
The Court says the majority award overlooked the sequence of obligations in the agreement. Under the agreement, the sale deed was to be executed only on payment of all the amounts due. Even the estimated price was to be paid in full by 01.03.2008, and it was not.
The final price also depended on a sanctioned building plan, which the builder did not secure.
The landowners had accepted six late instalments without protest. The Court holds that their failure to issue the written notice provided in the agreement, which gave 15 days to remedy a default, cured the delay for those six instalments. It did not wipe out the agreement's repeated statement that time was of the essence.
The arbitrators also set a new price. They directed payment at six times the agreed rate, taking the amount to ₹13,72,75,000, without any computation or reasoning. The Court says this direction was beyond the scope of the agreement and "defied logic".
The Court lists further errors:
- The award took into account a payment said to have been made under an earlier memorandum of understanding, although Clause 51 said all prior agreements stood superseded.
- It brought into the proposed sale deed part of the bungalow property that the agreement had left out.
- It fixed damages as an alternative relief in case specific performance was set aside, although the agreement did not provide for damages to either side.
The Court concludes that the two arbitrators replaced the express terms of the agreement with
new terms, as per their own fancies
Why the landowners must refund the money
Clause 53 said the agreement would come to an end on a default in payment. In that event, Clause 54 made the landowners liable to pay back the consideration paid to them, without interest, if no construction had been made on their share.
No construction had been made, yet the landowners kept the money. The Court says it was not open to them to "retain the said amount when they wished to retract from the agreement".
To spare the parties a fresh round of litigation, the Court uses Article 142 of the Constitution, its power to pass orders needed to do complete justice. As the landowners did not return the money when they terminated the agreement, the Court considers it fair that they return it with reasonable interest.
What the Court directs
The landowners must return the amounts paid to them under the agreement with simple interest at 9% per annum, from the date of each payment made by the builder till the date of actual refund. The builder's amounts lying in deposit with the courts may also be returned, with any interest accrued on them.
The appeals are disposed of in these terms. The parties bear their own costs.
