The Supreme Court holds that the Damodar Valley Corporation (DVC) may recover through its electricity tariff both depreciation on its assets and its contributions to a "Sinking Fund". The tariff is the price charged for power. The ruling concerns the tariff for the period 2009 to 2014 and affects the consumers who buy electricity from the DVC.
In a judgment delivered on 30 October 2026, the Court sets aside an order of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity, made in 2024, that had reopened the question in a review. It restores the Tribunal's original order dated 17 May 2019. It also imposes costs on the company that sought the review and on the Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL), which supported it.
What the dispute was about
The case is Damodar Valley Corporation v. Maithan Alloys Limited and others, Civil Appeal No. 11106 of 2024. The judgment is written by Justice K. Vinod Chandran, and is also signed by Justice J. B. Pardiwala.
The Sinking Fund, as the judgment describes it, is a portion of profits set apart to redeem, that is to repay, the bonds issued by the DVC. Depreciation is an allowance for the wear and tear of assets. The Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) fixed the DVC's tariff for 2009 to 2014 by an order passed in 2013.
Consumers appealed. The Tribunal upheld the CERC's order on its own reasoning and on the strength of an earlier Supreme Court decision, Bhaskar Shrachi Alloys Limited v. Damodar Valley Corporation, which had dealt with the same Sinking Fund issue for earlier years.
Nobody appealed against the Tribunal's order. One of the consumers, the first respondent, instead filed a review, which is a request to the same body to correct its own order. The review remained pending for five years.
The consumers argued that the DVC was getting a double benefit. The bonds pay for assets, the DVC is allowed depreciation on those assets, and the fund kept to repay the same bonds is also counted as an expense in the tariff. In the review, the Tribunal accepted this and ruled that the DVC could claim only one of the two.
What the Court decided
The Court sets aside the review order and allows the DVC's appeal. It calls the review "clearly illegal, totally misplaced" and in breach of judicial discipline.
The Court also finds a violation of Article 141 of the Constitution. It describes that Article as the constitutional backing which ensures that decisions of the highest court of the land are followed.
The Court's reasons
The Court relies on the law that governs the DVC. Section 40 of the Damodar Valley Corporation Act, 1948 requires the Corporation to make provision for depreciation and for reserve and other funds, at rates specified by the Auditor-General of India in consultation with the Central Government. Net profit is worked out only after that provision is made. The Court says this is a clear departure from general accounting principles.
The fourth proviso to Section 14 of the Electricity Act, 2003 keeps the provisions of the 1948 Act in force for the DVC so far as they are not inconsistent with the 2003 Act. The Court holds that Section 40 is not inconsistent with the Electricity Act.
The Court then points to Regulation 43 of the CERC's Tariff Regulations of 2009, which contains special provisions for the DVC. Under it:
- depreciation is computed at the rate stipulated by the Comptroller and Auditor General of India in terms of Section 40; and
- funds established under Section 40 are treated as items of expenditure to be recovered through tariff.
On the earlier decision, the Court says that although the words "duplication" or "double allowance" were not used there, the Sinking Fund was found permissible as an item of expenditure while the allowance for depreciation was also accepted. The Court finds no reason to doubt that decision. It adds that the Tribunal's original order had dealt specifically with the argument of double allowance.
On the limits of review, the Court cites State of West Bengal v. Kamal Sengupta. That decision says an error fit for review must be evident from the record itself, and that a tribunal exercising review cannot sit in appeal over its own decision. The Tribunal's review order, the Court says, does not fall under any of the principles set out there.
We cannot but observe that the Tribunal has gone haywire
Costs and directions
The Court notes that no appeal was filed against the 2019 order and that one of the consumers filed a review and waited five years to have it heard. It terms this "an abuse of process of law" and imposes a cost of Rs. 2,00,000 on the first respondent.
SAIL, a public sector undertaking, had intervened in the appeal to support the review order. The Court says it was ill-advised and imposes a cost of Rs. 1,50,000 on it.
Both amounts are to be paid to the Damodar Valley Corporation within one month from the date of the judgment. If they are not paid, interest at 18% per annum applies. The appeal is allowed with costs, in addition to these exemplary costs, and any pending applications stand rejected.
