The Supreme Court has ordered that a constable of the Central Industrial Security Force (CISF), removed from service in 2018 after a dispute over leave to care for his ailing wife, be taken back into service at once. In a judgment delivered on 16 November 2026, the Court holds that the findings of the departmental inquiry cannot be sustained and that the penalty of removal is shockingly disproportionate.

The ruling comes in Sumit Kumar v. Union of India (C.A. No. 14244-14245/2026). The bench consisted of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma, who wrote the judgment, and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh.

What the dispute was about

The constable joined the CISF in 2012 and was posted at its unit at the Uranium Corporation of India Limited, Jaduguda. He went on casual leave from 18 October 2017 to attend to his wife, who was unwell because of complications in pregnancy. According to him, she suffered a miscarriage and underwent surgery on 1 November 2017. His leave was extended until 3 December 2017.

He rejoined duty on 3 December 2017 and applied for twelve more days of leave. On 6 December 2017, stating that he was under acute mental stress, he tendered his resignation through the grievance portal. The resignation was closed and, the same day, he was told that twelve days of leave had been granted.

On 18 January 2018, the day he joined a new unit at Manuguru, Telangana, he was served with a charge memorandum, the formal document listing the accusations against an employee. It carried three charges:

  • that he did not appear before the Commandant on 6 December 2017 as ordered, and submitted a conditional resignation to pressure the unit administration;
  • that he tried to threaten senior officers through his relatives and made a video of his wife viral;
  • that he had earlier been given five minor penalties and had not mended his ways.

The Inquiry Officer held all three charges proved on 18 April 2018. On 1 May 2018 the disciplinary authority, the officer empowered to punish him, ordered his removal from service. His appeal was dismissed on 13 June 2018 and his revision petition on 4 January 2019.

The Delhi High Court dismissed his writ petition, a request to the court to examine the legality of official action, on 14 February 2024, and declined to review that decision on 12 July 2024. The High Court had held that "a blot is a blot, be it of the slightest degree, the magnitude thereof is of little importance."

The Court's reasons on the three charges

The Supreme Court notes that courts do not ordinarily re-examine evidence in disciplinary cases or replace the penalty chosen by the employer. They step in where the inquiry breaks the rules of natural justice, meaning the basic rules of a fair hearing, or where the punishment is so disproportionate that it shocks the conscience of the Court. Such a punishment would be arbitrary and would offend Article 14 of the Constitution.

On the first charge, the Court finds that the charge memorandum discloses no specific written direction that the constable disobeyed, and the inquiry record shows no material from that time proving the alleged communication. Without other reliable evidence, the charge of deliberate disobedience cannot rest on the allegation alone.

On the second charge, the Court records that a prosecution witness deposed that the video had not been sent to him by the constable and came from a different mobile number. The constable was at the unit while the video was recorded at the hospital. The Court says he cannot be held responsible merely because of his relationship with the persons involved.

Disciplinary liability must be founded upon misconduct attributable to the employee and established in the inquiry.

On the third charge, the Court holds that past misconduct for which an employee has already been punished cannot, by itself, be treated as a fresh instance of misconduct. It cannot be used to fill gaps in the proof of the present charges.

Flaws in the inquiry

The Court also notices procedural irregularities. The documents relied on against the constable were in English, a language he was not conversant with. He asked for Hindi translations on 24 January 2018, but received them only on 29 March 2018, after the prosecution witnesses had been examined.

His request for a defence assistant, a person who helps an employee present his case in an inquiry, was not accepted, despite Rule 36(8)(a) of the CISF Rules, 2001. Taken together, the Court finds, these circumstances show that he was not given an effective and meaningful opportunity to defend himself.

What the Court ordered

The penalty of removal from service is manifestly excessive and disproportionate to the misconduct, if any, established against the Appellant.

The appeals are allowed. The High Court's judgment of 14 February 2024 and its review order of 12 July 2024 are set aside, and the removal order of 1 May 2018, as affirmed in appeal and revision, is quashed.

The Court declines to send the matter back for a fresh inquiry, saying this would only prolong the proceedings and serve no useful purpose. The constable is to be reinstated in service forthwith, with all consequential benefits and 50% of the back wages, that is, half his pay, from the date of his removal until his reinstatement.