The Supreme Court of India has referred to a larger bench the question whether a person can be barred from contesting panchayat elections for having more than two children. In a judgment dated 4 November 2026, the Court says that its own ruling of 2003, which upheld such a bar, needs to be reconsidered because the fear of overpopulation on which it rested no longer matches the facts.

The Court does not strike down the Maharashtra provision in question. It sends the matter to the Chief Justice of India so that a larger bench can be formed, and it lets the woman sarpanch (elected village council head) who brought the appeal stay in office in the meantime.

What the dispute was about

The case is Mangala Bhimrao Ingle v. The Additional Commissioner, Amravati Division, C.A. No. 14165/2026. The appellant's election as Sarpanch of Kakoda Gram Panchayat was set aside on the ground that she had more than two children and was therefore disqualified from contesting panchayat elections. The provision applied was Section 14(1)(j-1) of the Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959.

The judgment records a finding that she gave birth to a third child in 2014 and was elected in the 2022 elections. Her advocate argued that there was no conclusive proof of the third child, because the place of issue of the birth certificate was allegedly not valid.

The bench of Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe says its enquiry was not about whether the High Court applied the law correctly. Its concern was whether such laws remain relevant when the basis for them has changed.

The 2003 ruling under review

In Javed v. State of Haryana, the Supreme Court examined the Haryana Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 and upheld the disqualification of persons with more than two living children from holding panchayat positions. According to the present judgment, that ruling relied on the perception then held about a population boom and its negative effect on the economy, and on the National Population Policy, 2000.

The bench notes that Javed was later relied upon in Rajbala v. State of Haryana, which upheld further conditions for panchayat candidates, including minimum educational qualifications. The Court records that those qualifications were acknowledged to make approximately 68% of Scheduled Caste women and 41% of Scheduled Caste men ineligible to contest.

The Court's reasons

The main reason is demographic. The Court relies on the Total Fertility Rate, or TFR, which is the average number of children expected to be born per woman. It notes that the TFR stood at 3.0 at the time of Javed and is now 1.9, according to the Sample Registration System, an official source.

A rate of 2.1 is regarded as the replacement level, at which one generation exactly replaces itself. India is therefore below replacement level fertility, the Court says, although its total population has not begun to decline. The bench warns of an ageing population and a declining share of people of working age.

"laws that penalise having more than two children have lost their relevance"

The judgment also looks abroad. It notes that Javed had referred to China's population control measures, and that China abandoned its one-child policy in 2015 and permitted three children in 2021, yet the expected revival in births has, by and large, not followed.

"We cannot ride into the future on a horse that is dead."

The bench also says such laws exclude a class of citizens from political representation on grounds that have little rational connection to their capacity to hold public office. It says women are disproportionately affected, since decisions about their reproductive choices are often driven by their husbands.

The Court also refers to Article 21 of the Constitution, which protects life and personal liberty. It says the right to make reproductive decisions is part of that guarantee, and that disqualification upon the birth of a third child places a person in the position of choosing between reproductive autonomy and continued participation in democratic governance.

The limits of the ruling

The bench states that the constitutional validity of the Maharashtra provision has not been challenged before it, and that it may not adjudicate directly upon that validity. It adds that the Court cannot direct the legislature to repeal or amend a law, but can examine whether the continued operation of a law remains constitutionally sustainable in changed circumstances.

In its conclusion the bench says the policy, and the reasons given for rejecting the challenge to it in Javed, have collapsed. The operative direction, however, is a reference. The final answer is left to a larger bench, and the appeal itself remains pending.

What the Court ordered

The Court refers the matter to a larger bench for reconsideration of the ratio, meaning the legal principle, laid down in Javed v. State of Haryana. The Registry is directed to place the judgment and order before the Chief Justice of India to constitute an appropriate bench.

While issuing notice earlier in the case, the Court had stayed the judgment and order passed by the High Court. That stay permits the appellant to continue in her elected position as Sarpanch of Kakoda Gram Panchayat.

"The interim order shall continue until disposal of the Civil Appeal."