The Supreme Court of India holds that a grandson cannot claim partition of land that came to his father as a separate share when the grandfather's property was divided among his heirs. In a judgment delivered on 6 November 2026, the Court dismisses an appeal brought on behalf of a son who sought a half share in a plot his father had already sold.

The ruling concerns the property of a Hindu man who dies without a will. The Court holds that the share each heir receives on partition becomes that heir's own property, and that a son's son gets no right in it by birth.

What the dispute was about

The case is J. Rajesh (Minor) through his mother and natural guardian J. Gomathi versus M. Kumaran (Dead) through LRs and others, Civil Appeal No. 7020 of 2012. The land in question measures 1811 sq. ft. and once belonged to the appellant's grandfather, the late N. Ramakrishnan.

In 1993, a sister of the appellant's father filed a suit for partition, that is, for division of the grandfather's property among those entitled to it. That suit ended in a compromise dated 3 February 1994, under which the father received the 1811 sq. ft. of land as his share. The appellant was born on 6 January 1994, before the decree was passed.

The father then sold the land to two buyers through sale deeds dated 3 April 1997 and 17 April 1997. Original Suit No. 1698 of 1997 was filed in the son's name through his mother, as he was a minor. It asked for partition and possession of a half share, on the footing that the land was joint family property inherited from the grandfather.

The suit did not challenge the compromise decree or the sale deeds. The father did not contest it. The buyers did, saying that the father was the absolute owner under the compromise decree.

How the lower courts ruled

The II Additional Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai passed a preliminary decree of partition, a first order in the son's favour. The buyers appealed. The High Court, by its judgment and order dated 11 August 2010, set that decree aside. It held that the son did not acquire a right by birth in property that came into his father's hands by partition after the grandfather's death.

The arguments before the Supreme Court

Counsel for the appellant relied on Section 29-A, inserted in the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 by the Hindu Succession (Tamil Nadu Amendment) Act, 1989, which gives daughters equal rights in coparcenary property. Coparcenary property is joint family property in which a member holds a right from birth. He argued that the appellant became a coparcener at birth and that the father was not competent to sell the whole of the land.

Counsel for the respondents argued that the case was governed by Section 8 of the same Act, which sets out who inherits when a Hindu man dies intestate, meaning without a will. The heirs listed in Class I of the Schedule to the Act take the property to the exclusion of all others. A son's son whose father is living is not on that list.

The Court's reasons

Justice Sunita Agarwal, writing for a bench that also included Justice Augustine George Masih, agrees with the respondents. The Court notes that the grandfather's heirs inherited as Class I heirs under Section 8. It says the right that a son's son had under the older personal Hindu law in his grandfather's property during his father's lifetime was not expressly saved by the legislature when the Act was passed.

The Court follows its earlier decision in Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Kanpur and others Vs. Chander Sen and others. As the judgment records, a son who inherits under Section 8 takes the property in his individual capacity and not as karta (head) of his own undivided family.

The express words of Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 cannot be ignored and must prevail.

Applying these decisions, the Court finds that under the compromise decree each heir became the exclusive owner of the property falling within his or her share. The heirs succeeded as tenants in common, each with a separate share, and the joint coparcenary did not continue. The father's portion, the Court says, "became his exclusive property in his individual capacity and cannot be said to be coparcenary".

The Court adds that the succession opened with the grandfather's death, evidently before the appellant was born, since the partition suit was filed in 1993. The date of that death was not disclosed. The appellant was not a surviving coparcener when his grandfather died. Neither Section 6 of the Act, which deals with coparcenary property, nor the Tamil Nadu amendment has any application to the facts.

What the Court ordered

The Court finds no infirmity, meaning no legal fault, in the High Court's judgment. Its operative order reads:

The appeal, thus, failed and hence stands dismissed with no order as to costs.

All pending applications are disposed of in the same terms. The effect is that the High Court's decision setting aside the preliminary decree of partition stands.