The Supreme Court has discharged a man accused of rape, cheating and bigamy by a woman with whom he lived for about seven years, holding that the material on record shows a consensual relationship between two adults and no offence. The ruling, delivered on 30 October 2026, ends a prosecution that began with a police case registered in 2011.

A discharge means the accused is released from the case before trial because the court finds no sufficient ground to proceed against him. Justice B.V. Nagarathna wrote the judgment for a bench that also included Justice R. Mahadevan. The case is Santhosh Kumar N.P. vs. State-Station House Officer, Crl.A. No. 5137-5138/2026.

What the dispute was about

The woman, a divorcee, said the man told her he was a bachelor and offered to marry her. In 1996 the two travelled to Mysuru, where she says they were married at a temple. They lived together as a couple until 2003.

In 2008 she filed a complaint under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, alleging neglect and seeking a place to live and money for expenses. In those proceedings the man disclosed that he was already married with two children. The complaint was dismissed on 31.08.2009, and her appeal also failed.

She then filed a private complaint, meaning a complaint made directly to a magistrate, alleging offences under Sections 376, 420, 493, 494 and 495 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. These cover rape, cheating, deceitfully making a woman believe she is lawfully married, marrying again while a spouse is alive, and doing so while hiding the earlier marriage. That complaint was dismissed on 04.04.2011 because it was not pursued.

A second complaint with similar allegations was sent to the police, and FIR No.503/2011 was registered at Kadirur Police Station. An FIR is the first information report on which the police open a criminal case.

How the case reached the Supreme Court

The man asked the trial court to discharge him. On 09.01.2015 the trial court refused, finding a prima facie case, that is, a case that appears made out on a first look at the material. The High Court of Kerala upheld that view on 21.05.2025, holding that consent given under a misconception of fact would amount to rape and that six years of living together did not cancel the initial deception alleged.

The Supreme Court issued notice on 18.07.2025 and stayed the trial court proceedings while it heard the appeals.

The Court's reasons

The Court applies Section 227 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973, which requires a judge to discharge an accused when there is not sufficient ground for proceeding. Relying on its earlier rulings in Union of India vs. Prafulla Kumar Samal and Sajjan Kumar vs. Central Bureau of Investigation, it says the test at this stage is whether the material shows it is probable or likely that the accused committed the offence.

On the rape charge, the Court notes that the woman does not deny that the man's brother told her of his existing marriage within a few months of their living together. She stayed with him for years afterwards. The Court finds it untenable that she continued to believe she was his legal wife only on his oral reassurances.

The relationship was consensual between two adults. The acts were not forced.

The Court holds that Section 376(2)(n), which punishes repeated rape of the same woman, is not made out, because the repeated acts were part of an ongoing relationship.

On cheating under Section 420, the Court says the offence requires that the deceit lead a person to hand over property or to make, alter or destroy a valuable security, a legal document creating or releasing a right. Nothing of that kind is alleged here.

On Sections 493, 494 and 495, the Court finds no prima facie proof of a valid marriage. The woman could not recall the name of the temple, and the priest's statement said only that he performed a marriage, with no further details. Papers such as signatures on IVF treatment documents and a joint account only suggest a long personal relationship, the Court says.

A caution on both sides

The Court records concern at failed relationships being turned into rape cases, and says courts must look at the whole relationship and not only its end. It adds: "Criminal law cannot be used as munitions to settle personal scores, exact revenge or coerce an individual to act in any particular way."

It also notes that rape remains heavily underreported and that women who are kept entirely in the dark about a partner's earlier marriage may have a real case. "We must emphasise that genuine cases must be pursued with vigour where the facts clearly show sexual assault and violence."

What the Court ordered

The Court holds that the trial court and the High Court ought to have discharged the man instead of sending him to trial. It allows the appeals, sets aside the High Court's order and the trial court's orders, and allows his application for discharge. He stands discharged from all the offences alleged against him.