Manu Gupta Vs Sujata Sharma & Ors on 4 December, 2023

CitationIK/44799346
Case NumberCS(OS) 142/2008
Date of Decision4 December 2023
CategoryDelhi High Court

Full Judgment Text

[Cites 47, Cited by 0]

Delhi High Court
Manu Gupta vs Sujata Sharma & Ors on 4 December, 2023

Author: Neena Bansal Krishna

Bench: Suresh Kumar Kait, Neena Bansal Krishna

* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Pronounced on:04th December, 2023

+ RFA(OS) 13/2016 & CM APPL. 6041/2016

MANU GUPTA .....Appellant

Through: Mr. Aslam Ahmed, Ms. Charu
Shriyam Singh & Mr. Abhishek
Dwivedi, Advocates. Ms.
Aakanksha Kaul, Amicus Curiae
with Mr. Manek Singh, Mr. Aman
Sahani & Mr. Harsh Ojha,
Advocates.
versus
SUJATA SHARMA & ORS. ..... Respondents

Through: Ms.Mala Goel, Advocate for R-1.
Ms. Anita Trehan, Dr. Sarita
Dhuper, Ms. Kajal Chandra, Ms.
Prerna Chopra, Mr. Divye Puri &
Ms. Sakshi Anand, Advocates.
Mr. Brajesh Kr. Srivastava, Mr.
Deo Prakash Sharma, Mr. Manoj
Yadav & Mr. Umesh Kr. Gupta,
Advocates for R-9 & 10.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURESH KUMAR KAIT
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA

J U D G M E N T

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 1 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J

"Real change, enduring change, happens one step at a time"

- Ruth Bader Ginsburg

1. Men and women historically were born equal. However, over a
period of time, with the advancement of civilization and hierarchical
division of society, women have been pigeonholed according to gender
roles which progressed into an act of prelation that has relegated them to a
secondary position in society. Consequently, the once egalitarian society
became a breeding ground for chauvinism and discrimination in the form
of Sati, Child Marriage, Sexual Harassment, Domestic Violence, Dowry
Harassment and such like disparages. Legislature has time and again,
brought forth reforms to overcome this bigotry and free women from the
shackles of such specious fetters devised by mankind thereby enabling her
to achieve her full potential and march shoulder to shoulder with men.

2. Despite robust legislations, real change has been slow due to the
pervasive ambivalence and deeply ingrained stereotypes. This is where
Courts assume significance for facilitation of implementation of the laws
resulting in actualisation for the stakeholders. This has been true,
especially in the laws conferring rights to women. It is known that though
the right of women to own property came to be recognized under the
Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the grim reality is that women were
compelled, by their circumstances and family members, to forgo their
rights in property. The tenacious role of Courts in upholding such rights
of women has propelled them to agitate their long overdue entitlements,
making Courts the game changer.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 2 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
3. Similarly, the Amendment of 2005 to the Hindu Succession Act,
1956 which has conferred coparcenary rights to the women, equivalent to
that of men, is a quintessence of another reform in law relating to women
empowerment. However, the unwavering certitude in marginalisation of
women, so deeply entrenched in Society, is perceived to be imperilled by
the prospect of a woman taking the position of Karta in an HUF, a role
that was traditionally assumed by men.

4. This disinclination in accepting a woman as a Karta, despite having
been conferred equal rights equal coparcenary rights as men, has emerged
in the present case, leaving the ball in our Court.

5. The present Appeal has been preferred by the appellant/Manu
Gupta (the defendant No.1 in the main Suit), against the Judgement dated
22.12.2015 whereby the Suit for Declaration for declaring the plaintiff
(respondent No.1 herein) as the Karta of Late Shri D.R. Gupta and Sons,
HUF, has been allowed.

6. The appellant and the respondents, being Hindus and governed by
the Mitakshara Law, are the descendants of Late Shri D.R. Gupta, son of
Late Shri Sunder Das Gupta, who expired on 01.10.1971. Admittedly,
Late Shri D.R. Gupta constituted a Hindu Joint Family (HUF) known as
D.R Gupta and Sons (HUF) since 05.01.1963 comprising of himself and
his five sons. The members of the HUF are reflected in the chart below: -

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 3 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
7. Late Shri D.R. Gupta, voluntarily put his immoveable property
commonly known as No. 4, University Road, Delhi, and shares in Motor
and General Finance Ltd., besides other moveable and immoveable
properties in the common hotch-potch and executed an Affidavit dated
05.01.1963 declaring that all properties shall belong to the Hindu

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 4 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
Undivided Family (HUF) of which he shall be the "Karta" with right of
survivorship and all other incidents of undivided coparcenary on his wife
and his five sons namely Late Shri K.M. Gupta, Late Shri M.H. Gupta,
Late Shri R.N. Gupta, Late Shri B.N. Gupta and Late Shri J.N. Gupta as
members. "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF", thus came to own the following
immovable and moveable properties which are the subject matter of the
present Suit. The details of immoveable and moveable properties are as
under: -

(a) Immoveable Property --
(i) No. 4, University Road, Delhi. This property was
purchased vide a Registered Sale Deed dated 15.07.1943 by
Late Shri D.R. Gupta from Mr. J.C. Roberts. Copy of the
Sale Deed dated 15.07.1943 is filed on record.
(b) Moveable Properties --
(i) Shares of Motor and General Finance Ltd.,
(ii) Deposits with Motor and General Finance Ltd.,
(iii) Bank of Account in Bank of India, Asaf Ali Road,
(iv) Bank Account in Vijaya Bank, Ansari Road.
8. Admittedly, "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF" is assessed to Income Tax
and has been filing Returns for the HUF property and the PAN Number
allotted to the HUF was AAA HD 4230 M. All the assets belonging to the
HUF, barring the immovable property, were disposed of in the 1980s.

9. Over a period of time all the sons of late Shri D.R. Gupta expired.
Shri R.N. Gupta was the last Karta of "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF", who
expired on 14.02.2006. The question thus, arose as to who would acquire
the status of the Karta of the HUF after his demise. The respondent No.1
as well as other members of the "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF", exchanged
various e-mails regarding respondent No. 1, Sujata daughter of Late Shri

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 5 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
K.M. Gupta becoming the Karta of the HUF, who in view of the law as
amended in the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2006, claimed to be
the next Karta of the "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF" being the eldest
Coparcener.

10. Mr. Mukul Gupta (respondent No. 5), Ms. Suneeta Sudershan -
represented by her LRs (respondent Nos. 6A & 6B) Mr. Bharat Gupta
(respondent No. 8), Ms. Anita Trehan (respondent No. 12), Dr. Sarita
Dhupar (respondent No. 13) and Mrs. Radhika Seth (respondent No. 15)
are the Coparceners. Ms. Janki Gupta (respondent No. 7), Mr. Raj Gupta
(respondent No. 11), Ms. Veena Gupta (respondent No. 14) and Mrs.
Shanta K. Mohan (i) are the members of the HUF. They all have not
raised any objection to Ms. Sujata Sharma being the Karta of the HUF.

11. Mr. Manu Gupta (appellant), Mr. Vasu Gupta (respondent
No. 2), Ms. Gita Lal (respondent No. 3) and Ms. Aditi Desai (respondent
No. 17), are the coparceners who have opposed respondent No. 1
becoming the Karta. Ms. Meera Sawhney (respondent No. 9) and Ms.
Gargi Gupta (respondent No. 10) initially submitted an affidavit before
the learned Single Judge consenting to accept any person determined by
the Court as the Karta, however, they have later staked a claim to be the
eligible Karta by stating that respondent No. 1 is not a Coparcener under
law.

12. The appellant/Manu Gupta, in objection to respondent no.1‟s claim,
declared himself as the Karta of HUF and had correspondence in this
capacity with the Defence Estate Officer.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 6 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
13. This led to filing of the present Civil Suit in 2006 by respondent
No.1/Sujata Sharma seeking a Declaration that she is the Karta of "D.R.
Gupta & Sons HUF".

14. As matter stood thus, the respondent No. 9/Ms. Meera Sawhney
filed a suit bearing C.S. (OS) No. 142/2008 titled Meera Sawhney vs Smt.
Raj Gupta for Declaration that an Oral Settlement dated 18.01.1999;
Memorandum of Settlement dated 01.04.1999 and the Will dated
17.09.2000 be declared as null and void and sought partition of "D.R.
Gupta & Sons HUF", Rendition of Accounts and Permanent Injunction
for restraining the other members of the family from interfering in
peaceful possession of her share in the property. The respondent
No. 1/Sujata Sharma was defendant No. 4 in the said Suit and opposed the
claims made by Ms. Meera Sawhney.

15. On the basis of pleadings, the Issues were framed by the learned
Single Judge vide Order dated 15.09.2008 which read as under: -

"1. Whether the suit has been valued properly and proper
court fee has been paid thereon? (OPP)
2. Whether the suit for declaration, is maintainable in its
present form? (OPP)
3. Whether there exists any coparcenary property or
HUF at all?(OPP)

4. Whether the plaintiff is a member of D.R. Gupta and
Sons HUF? And if so, to what effect? (OPP)

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 7 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
5. Whether the interest of the plaintiff separated upon the
demise of her father Sh. K.M. Gupta in 1984? (OPD)
6. Assuming existence of a D.R. Gupta and Sons HUF,
whether the plaintiff can be considered to be an integral
part of the HUF, particularly after her marriage in 1977,
and whether the plaintiff has ever participated in the
affairs of the HUF as a coparcener, and its effect? (OPP)
7. Assuming existence of D.R. Gupta and Sons HUF,
whether the plaintiff is a coparcener of and legally
entitled to be the Karta?(OPP)
8. What is the effect of the amendment in the Hindu
Succession Act, in 2005 and has it made any changes in
the concept of Joint Family or its properties in the law of
coparcenary? (OPP)
9. Relief."

16. The respondent No.1/Sujata Sharma deposed as PW1 in support of
her claim. She also examined PW2/Ritu Grover, PW3/Mr. N.V.
Satyanarayan, Defence Estate Officer and PW4/Shri Sanjay Saxena,
Book Binder, Department of Delhi Archives, Delhi Government, Delhi.

17. The appellant/Manu Gupta deposed as DW1 and was
cross examined by the counsels for respondent Nos. 1, 9 and10.

18. The learned Single Judge in the impugned judgment observed that
the necessary qualification for becoming a Karta was being a Coparcener
of the HUF. The only impediment that disallowed a woman from

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 8 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
becoming a Karta was the lack of this necessary qualification. The
Amended Section 6 of the The Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (hereinafter
referred to as the "Act, 1956") was introduced in 2005 as a socially
beneficial legislation to give equal rights of inheritance to Hindu males
and females; the marriage of the plaintiff did not affect her rights in the
Coparcenary as the provision clearly defines the statutory right of a
female to be absolute without admitting any exception or restriction such
as marriage. With the removal of this disqualifying factor, nothing
prevents the eldest female Coparcener from becoming the Karta of an
HUF. It was held that the Amendment, brought in Section 6 of the Act,
1956 by the Amendment Act, 2005, does not impose any restriction on
the right of a woman of being coparcener and she cannot be denied a
status of Karta to manage the affairs, including the property of HUF. The
Suit was decided in favour of the plaintiff/respondent No.1and she was
declared the Karta of "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF".

19. Aggrieved by the Judgement dated 22.12.015, the present Appeal
has been filed by Shri Manu Gupta.

20. The challenge to the Judgement by the appellant/Manu Gupta is
essentially premised on the ground that his cousin sister i.e., respondent
No. 1 admittedly, was married on 28.02.1969 and had become an active
member of the HUF in her marital home. She consequently became
disconnected with the activities of the "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF" and
has neither participated in any coparcenary activities till date nor had she
resided in any of the HUF property subsequent to her marriage as can also
be evinced from her own deposition. It is claimed that Kartaship owes its

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 9 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
provenance to Hindu customs and laws, which cannot be outmanoeuvred
by the opinion or acts of the members of the family. The intent behind the
Amendment is solely to confer equality in the scheme of division of
properties and does not confer the role of Kartaship to women as the
same is still confined to the senior most male Coparcener in the family as
provided under the Mitakshara School of Hindu Law. It is reiterated that
the law in regard to Kartaship has remained unchanged by the
Amendment and the settled position remains that only the eldest Hindu
male can become a Karta.

21. Thus, notwithstanding the 2005 Amendment to the Act, 1956, a
daughter cannot become the Karta of the HUF of her father‟s family
though she may only be recognised as the manager of a Joint Hindu
Family.

22. It is further stated that Section 6 of the Act, 1956 (as amended in
2005) only recognises the right of daughters to have an interest in the
coparcenary and the same cannot be equated with her right to become a
Karta. Barring this right to be recognised as a coparcener, no other
change has been brought with respect to HUF which is still governed by
the Mitakshara School of Hindu Law. As per this School of Law, a Joint
Hindu Family is one that traces its descendants through a common male
ancestor and includes wives and unmarried daughters as their members.

23. Further, the learned Single Judge has failed to consider that Section
4 of the Act, 1956 clearly stipulates that the Act, 1956 has an overriding
effect only on customs that had been expressly overruled by provisions of

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 10 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
the Act and no provision apropos the management of an HUF has been
codified under the Act.

24. "Kartaship" is a conferment of customary law and traditions.
Given that the Amendment Act, 2005 provides a statutory recognition to
female as coparceners, one must read the customary law in tandem with
the statutory right which clearly leads to the inference that the parity
sought to be achieved by the Amendment was with respect to equal
interest in the coparcenary property. Thus, the entitlement to become a
Karta with its specific roles and responsibilities, is completely
distinguishable from the statutory right of equal rights in property given
to a female as a Coparcener.

25. It is asserted that the learned Single Judge failed to appreciate that a
daughter upon marriage, ceases to be a member of her father‟s family as
she becomes a member of her husband‟s family and with her marriage,
her Gotra (lineage) also changes. The marriage symbolises daughter
being reborn into her husband‟s family upon marriage and customarily, a
new name post marriage was given to a woman. The respondent No. 1
had thus, ceased to be a member of the D.R. Gupta Family upon her
marriage in 1969 and has become a member of her matrimonial family. It
is a settled position of law that a person cannot be a member of two Joint
Hindu Families at the same time. It is contended that a woman would
anyway acquire certain rights in her husband‟s home, while the vice versa
is not possible. This furthers the asymmetry in the rights of a woman as
she acquires rights in her father‟s property and husband‟s property. Thus,
a woman becomes a member of her husband‟s family and remains a

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 11 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
Coparcener in her father‟s family; however, a man is only a Coparcener in
his father‟s family.

26. It is reiterated that a woman ceases to be a member of her father‟s
family upon marriage. Reliance has been placed on Narendra vs. K.
Meena (2016) 9 SCC 455; Kamesh Panjiyar vs. State of Bihar 2005 (2)
SCC 388 for the same. Thus, the learned Single Judge has failed to
appreciate that respondent No. 1 did not have the locus to file the present
Suit after her marriage.

27. It is further submitted that the learned Single Judge failed to
consider the judgement of the Apex Court in Shreya Vidyarthi vs. Ashok
Vidyarthi AIR 2016 SC 139 where it was held that a woman cannot
become a Karta even after the 2005 Amendment as it keeps the erstwhile
legal position on Kartaship intact which is evident from the true nature of
the amended and unamended Section 6 of the Act, 1956.

28. The Law Commission in its 174th Report dated 05.05.2000, while
recommending that women should exercise all equal rights as a
Coparcener, also stated that a woman cannot be a Karta. It was based on
these recommendations that the Legislature amended Section 6 to the Act,
1956; had the intent of this Amendment been to recognise the right of a
woman to become a Karta, the Amendment would have expressly stated
so. Thus, the impugned Judgement dated 22.12.2015 is premised on
incorrect appreciation of change in law brought by the Amendment Act,
2005 to the Act, 1956.

29. It is further argued that a Karta takes decisions on behalf of the
family which has a binding effect on them. He has the right to represent

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 12 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
the family in litigations, arbitrations and settlements by way of
compromise and it is thus, imperative for the Karta to be an integral
member of the family. The role of a Karta is multifaceted and not limited
to a managerial role. Along with being a financial head of the family, he
is also their religious, social and spiritual head. There are several Hindu
customs performed by a Karta that only an eldest male can perform such
as Mukhaanghi (lighting the funeral pyre), Shraddha, Kanyadaan to name
a few which are imperative incidences to be considered while
adjudicating the claim of the respondent No.1 to be declared as a Karta.
The learned Single Judge also omitted to appreciate that religious and
other sanctimonious activities cannot be performed by a woman during
her menstrual period. In fact, it is appellant who performed the last rights
of respondent No.1‟s father as he did not have a son. In a way, the
appellant has been fulfilling the role of a Karta since long while
respondent No.1 has never acted in this capacity.

30. Learned counsel for the appellant has further argued that it is a
settled position of law that in case of the unfortunate demise of the father,
the wife, who is the mother of minor sons, can be the manager of the HUF
until her sons attain majority. This, however, does not mean that the
mother becomes the Karta of the HUF. In extension to this rationale, it is
submitted that a married woman can be required to perform a managerial
role in the HUF in her matrimonial home. However, any right to become
a Karta in her father‟s family would clash with the rights in her
matrimonial home resulting in a conflict of interest and a moral dilemma
on where her loyalties should lie.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 13 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
31. It is submitted that the learned Single Judge failed to consider that
by declaring respondent No. 1 as the Karta of the "D.R. Gupta & Sons
HUF", the de facto and de jure control of the HUF properties and
business would lie in the hands of the husband of respondent No.1 and
would result in complications in the assessment of Income Tax.

32. The law traditionally recognises a Karta as the senior most male
member of the family as such a male commands respect and authority
over the family members. Since respondent No. 1 lacks such attributes
and because she has not been an integral part of the family, she cannot
claim to be the Karta of the HUF. Thus, only the appellant, being the
senior most male Coparcener, would be in a position to run and manage
an HUF efficiently.

33. It is further argued by the appellant that the Suit for Declaration
was filed by respondent No. 1/Smt. Sujata Sharma in retaliation to the
objections raised by the appellant when she attempted to sell the
Charitable Trust created by Late Shri D.R. Gupta by undervaluing the
said property. It is evident that respondent No. 1‟s objective in filing the
Suit was to gain control over the property and sell the same in order to
unjustly enrich herself.

34. The appellant has further submitted that the demise of Shri R.N.
Gupta after 2005 Amendment to Section 6 of the Act, 1956 resulted in a
deemed partition of the HUF and thus, respondent No. 1 cannot claim to
be a Coparcener.

35. The appellant in his Written Submissions has further stated that
the father of respondent No.1 passed away on 18.02.1984. The 2005

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 14 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
Amendment, being prospective in nature, would apply to respondent
No. 1 only if her father was surviving when the Amendment came into
force. The share of the deceased Coparcener to which his legal heirs are
entitled gets crystallised upon his death as held in State Bank of India vs.
Ghamandi Ram, AIR 1969 1330. Thus, none of the daughters, other than
Ms. Meera Sawhney and Ms. Gargi Gupta would be entitled to be the
Coparceners. Reliance was placed on Prakash and Ors vs. Phulvati
(2016) 2 SCC 36 and Danamma @ Suman Supur and Anr vs. Amar and
Ors, 2018 SCC OnLine SC 63 in support of this stance. It is argued that
the judgement in Danamma @ Suman Supur (supra) consciously kept the
sanctimonious status of a Karta outside the purview of the social
inequities that was sought to be addressed through Amendment Act of
2005.

36. It is pointed out that in the Suit for Partition filed by respondent
No. 9, wherein respondent No.1/Smt. Sujata Sharma who is defendant
No. 4, has surprisingly taken the stance in her Written Statement that the
HUF property has already been partitioned. In such a scenario, respondent
No.1 cannot claim to be a Coparcener of "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF".

37. Subsequently, in reference to Vineeta Sharma vs. Rakesh Sharma
(2020) 9 SCC 1, the appellant conceded that he does not wish to challenge
the coparcenary right of respondent No.1. However, since the said
judgment does not deal with her right to become a Karta, no support can
be drawn by respondent No.1 to claim such a title of Karta. It is reiterated
that the case of Vineeta Sharma (supra) is not applicable to the case of
respondent No. 1 as she in her Written Statement filed in the Suit filed by

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 15 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
Meera Sawhney and Ors. (supra) has taken the stand that the HUF
property has already been partitioned prior to the Amendment Act of
2006 coming into effect

38. The respondent No.1/Sujata Sharma, in her Written
Arguments, submitted that 10 out of 17 respondents have given their
affidavits of "No Objection" for respondent No.1 to become the Karta of
the "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF". It is further stated that Section 6 of the
Act, 1956 does not make any distinction between a married, unmarried,
widowed, educated or illiterate daughter, as being a daughter of a
Coparcener is the sole qualification under the law. Moreover, the
performance of ceremonies like Kanyadaan, Satphere, Panigrahana do
not take away a woman‟s identity of being a daughter. In response to the
appellant‟s contention on the change in the Gotra of respondent No. 1
after marriage, it was vociferously argued that marriage does not change
the blood of a person and she still remains the daughter of her paternal
family. Reliance was placed on Vineeta Sharma vs. Rakesh Sharma
(supra) and Ganduri Koteshwar Ramma vs. Chakri Yanadi & Anr. (2011)
9 SCC 788to argue that a daughter is a Coparcener who has the same
rights as a son. Further, the role of a Karta is conferred on the senior most
member of the family as held in Tribhovan Das Tamboli vs. Gujarat
Revenue Tribunal and Ors. AIR 1991 SC 1538. Considering that only a
Coparcener can become a Karta of an HUF as held in Commissioner of
Income Tax vs. Seth Govind Ram Sugar Mills, AIR 1966 SC 24, a woman
can become a Karta if she is the eldest Coparcener.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 16 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
39. In response to the appellant‟s assertions of discharging his
responsibilities in the nature of Karta since long, it is averred that
respondent No. 1 has been dealing with the Defence Estate Officer from
2006 regarding the HUF property and had also filed Objections to the
notification of the Delhi Development Authority, paid House Tax, got a
Pan Card issued and the bank account revived.

40. The respondent Nos. 9 and 10, in their Written Submissions,
contended that in view of the decision in Prakash vs. Phulvati (supra),
respondent No. 1 is not a Coparcener as her father had expired on
17.02.1983 i.e., prior to the commencement of the Hindu Succession
(Amendment) Act, 2005. Thus respondent No. 9 is the eldest legally
eligible Karta of "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF" as her father Late Shri R.N.
Gupta was alive on 09.09.2005 and was then acting as the Karta. Thus,
the judgement of the learned Single Judge is per incurium for not
applying the decision of Prakashi (supra). Further, the judgment in
Danamma @ Suman Supur (supra) affirms and reiterates the finding in
Prakash vs Phulvati (supra).

41. Further, reliance has been placed on the judgements in Ganga
Saran vs. Civil Judge, Hapur, Ghaziabad AIR 1991 All 114 (FB); Indo
Swiss vs. Umrao AIR 1981 P& H 213 (FB); Kulbhushan Kumar vs. State
of Punjab AIR 1984 P & H 55 (FB); Special Land Acquisition Officer vs.
Municipal Corporation AIR 1888 Bom9 (FB) and Gopa Manish Vora vs.
UOIILR (2009) IV Delhi 61(DB).

42. It is submitted that once a daughter has been made a Coparcener on
the same footing as a son, any prohibition or fetters on her right is

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 17 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
patently unfair and illegal. Centuries of injustice to a female cannot be
continued even after the law has accorded equal rights to a woman. Equal
rights will form the gateway to equal treatment of a daughter and
reinforce her honour and dignity in the family of her birth. It was thus
asserted that the legally eligible eldest Coparcener is respondent
No. 9/Meera Sawhney.

43. The respondent Nos. 12 and 13, in their Written Submissions,
have extended their support to respondent No. 1. It is stated that a
daughter continues to be a Coparcener as well as a member of the Joint
Hindu family after marriage. This implies that a daughter can be a
member of two HUFs after marriage. Relying on Vineeta Sharma (supra),
it is submitted that the coparcenary right under Section 6 of the Act, 1956
is available to daughters born before or after the Amendment in 2005 in
the same manner as a son with the same rights and liabilities. Further,
they supported the contentions of respondent No.1 that a daughter can
become a Karta if she is the senior most coparcener.

44. Ms. Aakanksha Kaul had been appointed as the Amicus Curiae
vide Order dated 15.01.2021 by this Court who has provided assistance
to this court on two questions, namely: -

A. Whether a married daughter can be the Karta of a Hindu
Undivided Family (HUF)?

B. Whether the Hindu Succession Amendment Act, 2005 to
Section 6 of the Act, 1956 is retrospective?

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 18 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
45. She submitted that Question B has already answered by the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the affirmative in Vineeta Sharma (supra)
wherein it is held that Section 6 as amended in 2005 is not retrospective
as concluded transactions or vested rights cannot be reopened or affected.
The provision is rectroactive in its application as it confers right based on
an antecedent event of birth. The only qualification for becoming a Karta
of an HUF is that the concerned person must be a Coparcener. Reliance
was placed on Tribhovan Das Haribhai Tamboli (supra) to describe the
role of a person appointed as a Karta.

46. Ms. Aakanksha Kaul, learned Amicus Curiae, further submitted
that earlier only a male could become the Coparcener of an HUF as the
coparcenary rights were confined only to males. Thus, the sole ground for
disentitling a daughter from becoming a Karta no longer survives.
Therefore, if a daughter is the senior most Coparcener, then she must
become the Karta.

47. Further, a daughter does not cease to be a Coparcener in view of
her marriage as the Amendment does not distinguish between a married
and an unmarried daughter. The Amendment to Section 6 of the Act, 1956
clearly states that a daughter becomes a Coparcener in the same manner
as a son. When a son does not cease to be a Coparcener upon marriage,
the same benefit should be extended to a daughter as well. In fact, it can
no longer be said that a daughter ceases to be a member of her father‟s
family upon marriage as observed in Khushi Ram & Ors. vs. Nawal Singh
& Ors. 2021 SCC OnLine SC 128. The Apex Court in the landmark
judgment of Vineeta Sharma (supra) as well has observed that the

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 19 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
Amendment Act of 2005 could never have intended to discriminate
against a married and an unmarried woman.

48. On the basis of the recommendations of the Law Commission of
India in its 174th Report on "Properly Rights of Women: Proposed
Reforms under the Hindu Law", the Legislature has not included the
distinction drawn in State Amendments between a married and an
unmarried daughter in the 2005 Amendment. Thus, all daughters of
Coparceners are entitled to become a Coparcener, which also entitled
them to become a Karta.

49. Ms. Aakanksha Kaul, learned Amicus Curiae, has reiterated the
aforementioned contentions in her oral arguments.

50. Submissions heard from the learned counsels of all the parties
and the Written Submissions as well as the record perused.

51. Based on the facts and submissions made by the parties, it is
apodictic that the appellant is not at odds with the coparcenary interest of
a daughter; however, he assails the coparcenary interest as well as the
right of respondent No.1 to become the Karta of the "D.R. Gupta & Sons
HUF" by relying on the Written Statement of latter in another Suit. The
respondent Nos. 9 and 10 persist on their stance that respondent No. 1 is
not a Coparcener as the father of Ms. Sujata Sharma expired before the
Amendment Act, 2005 came into effect. The primary point of contention
is thence, her claim to become a Karta of the "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF".

52. Before delineating the rights of the appellant and the respondents, it
is imperative to examine the findings of the learned Single Judge on the
implications of the 2005 amendment to Section 6 of the Act, 1956.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 20 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
ISSUE NO. 8: --

"What is the effect of the amendment in the Hindu
Succession Act, in 2005 and has it made any changes in the
concept of Joint Family or its properties in the law of
coparcenary? (OPP)"
53. The appellant has contended that Section 6 of the Act, 1956 defines
only the rights with respect to inheritance of property and not its
management by a Karta which continues to be governed by the customs
and the interpretation of the ancient texts of Hindu religion. It is argued
that the statutory enlargement of rights of a woman to be a Coparcener
and the devolution of interest in the coparcenary property has been made
under Section 6 of Act, 1956 and it does not extend to Kartaship.
Therefore, the learned Single Judge ought not to have exceeded the intent
and purpose of the Act, 1956 and amended Section 6 of the Act, 1956 to
conclude that a recognition of a woman as a Coparcener included the right
of being a Karta.

54. To determine the contention raised by the appellant, it becomes
pertinent to refer to the concept of Joint Hindu Family and HUF under the
traditional Hindu Law.

55. A Joint Hindu Family consists of male members descended
lineally from a common male ancestor, together with their mothers, wives
or widows and unmarried daughters. They are bound together by the
fundamental principle of Sapindaship or family relationship, which is the
essential feature of the institution. The cord that knits the members of the

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 21 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
family is not property but the relationship of one another as explained in
the Commissioner of Income Tax vs. Luxminarayan (1935) 59 Bom 618.

56. In Raghavachariar‟s Hindu Law, 5th Edition at Page 838, the
concept "coparcenary" was defined which is as under: -

"Co-parcenary is a narrower over body than a joint
family and consist of only those persons who have taken
by birth and interest in the property of the holder for the
time being and who can enforce a partition whenever
they like. It commences with the common ancestor and
includes the holder of joint property and only those males
in his male line who are not removed from him by more
than three degrees. The reason why coparcenership is so
limited is to be found in the tenet of the Hindu religion
that only male descendants up to three degrees can offer
spiritual ministration to an ancestor. Only males can be
coparceners."
57. From the aforesaid explanation, it may be observed that a "Joint
Hindu Family" consists of male members descended lineally from a
common male ancestor and included their unmarried daughters, wives,
mothers and widows. A "coparcenary" is a narrower body which is a
subset within a Joint Hindu Family where an interest in the property is
created by birth. Though a joint family status is a result of birth, the
possession of joint property is only an appendage and not prerequisite for
the constitution of such a family as held in Haridas vs. Devaki Bai, 1926
SCC OnLine Bom 76. On the other hand, a "coparcenary" is created
only when there is joint or coparcenary property.

Position of Manager: --

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 22 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
58. The question which thus, needs to be answered is whether
recognition of a woman as a coparcener carries with it a necessary
incident of becoming a Karta to assume the management of the
coparcenary property.

59. In Raghavachariar's Hindu Law, a "manager" of a Joint Hindu
Family has been described as a senior member of the family who is
entitled to manage the properties and, in his absence, the next senior most
male member of the family, is its manager provided he is not
incapacitated from acting as such by illness or other sufficient cause. At
Page 295, the position of a "manager" of a Joint Hindu Family is
explained which is as under: -

"276. Position of Manager. - In a Hindu family the
Karta or manager occupies a position superior to that of
the other members in so far as he manages the property
or business or looks after the family interests on behalf
of the other members. The managership of the joint
family property comes to a person by birth and he does
not owe his position as manager to be presumed to the
consent of his coparceners."

60. In B M Gandhi's Hindu Law, the concept of "managership" or
"Kartaship" has been similarly explained which is as under: -

"19. Manager (Karta): -
(a) Who is/Who can be. The Hindu joint family is
governed by the principle of subordination. Its affairs are
managed by one person, called the Karta or the
manager."

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 23 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
61. It was explained by Bombay High Court in Gansavant Balsavant
vs. Narayan Dhond Savant, (1883) ILR 7 Bom 467 that a Hindu family
may be regarded as a corporation whose interests are necessarily centred
in the manager, the presumption being that the manager is acting for the
family unless the contrary is shown. Unless the Karta or manager
relinquishes his right or there are exceptional, extraordinary or compelling
circumstances, juniors in the family cannot exercise this right. Even if the
Karta is a lunatic, the juniors cannot alienate the property without
obtaining a Court‟s order under the Lunacy Act, 1912.

62. In Tribhuvandas Haribhai Tamboli (supra), the Apex Court
observed that the managership of the joint family property goes to a
person by birth and is regulated by seniority. He is a "primus inter
pares". It was further observed that the father is ordinarily the manager of
the family consisting of himself, his descendants and other relations. After
the father‟s death his elder son generally becomes the manager. It is
possible that a more capable son may become the manager, or it is also
possible that the senior member may give up his right of management and
a junior may act in his place when the senior member is incapacitated due
to reasons of health. Thus, the right to become a manager depends
upon the fundamental fact that the person on whom it devolves was a
Coparcener of the joint family. Consequently, under traditional Hindu
Law, no female (e.g., a widow) member could be a manager or Karta of a
joint family.

63. From the above discussion, it may be concluded that birth in the
Joint Hindu Family, seniority by age and the status of being a

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 24 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
Coparcener are the necessary qualifications to become a Karta. The
traditional Law nowhere proscribed a female from being a manager but
the requisite of being the "senior most male" was the necessary corollary
of the fact that only male members of the Joint Hindu Family who were
born within the degrees of coparcenary, were given the status of a
Coparcener.

64. This limitation has been redressed by Amendment to Section 6 of
the Act, 1956 which now confers the equal status of Coparcener on
woman equating her rights to be at par with a son. Therefore, having
acquired the status of Coparcener, the respondent No.1 should be entitled
to acquire the status of Karta.

65. The appellant, on the other hand, has contended that the
Legislative Object behind the Amendment Act, 1956 as reflected in its
Preamble and the Title of Section 6 (as amended in 2005) is solely to
codify the law on succession of property and does not change the
traditional Hindu law or amend the necessary qualification of being a
male Coparcener to become the Karta of an HUF.

66. This contention of the appellant gives rise to the question of
whether the heading of the provision or the Preamble of the Act, 1956 can
be used to restrict the scope of express words used within the body of the
section.

Title of Section 6 of the Act, 1956: -

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 25 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
67. The title of Section 6 of the Act, 1956 reads as "devolution of
interest in coparcenary property" and the relevant portion of the Section
has been extracted below: -

"―(1) On and from the commencement of the Hindu
Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 (39 of 2005), in a
Joint Hindu family governed by the Mitakshara law, the
daughter of a coparcener shall,―
(a) by birth become a coparcener in her own right the
same manner as the son;
(b) have the same rights in the coparcenery property as
she would have had if she had been a son;
(c) be subject to the same liabilities in respect of the said
coparcenery property as that of a son, and any reference
to a Hindu Mitakshara coparcener shall be deemed to
include a reference to a daughter of a coparcener:
Provided that nothing contained in this sub-section shall
affect or invalidate any disposition or alienation
including any partition or testamentary disposition of
property which had taken place before the 20th day of
December, 2004."
68. In the case of Raichurmatham Prabhakar vs. Rawatmal Dugar
(2004) 4 SCC 766, the Apex Court observed that the heading or title of a
provision plays a limited role in the construction of statutes. In the event
of a dispute between the plain language of the provision and the meaning
of the heading or title, the interpretation that is clearly and obviously
visible from the language of the provision thereunder, shall prevail.

69. Thus, the title of Section 6 of the Act, 1956 cannot form the basis
for restricting the express statutory right conferred under the provision.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 26 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
Preamble of the Act, 1956: -

70. A Preamble lists the principle objectives of an Act which forms an
internal aid of interpretation. The Preamble to the Act, 1956 reads as "An
Act to amend and codify the law relating to Interstate succession among
Hindus."

71. As early as in 1956, the House of Lords in
Prince Ernest of Hanover vs. Attorney General (1957) 1 All E.R. 49 held
that "When there is a preamble it is generally in its recitals that the
mischief to be remedied and the scope of the Act are described. It is,
therefore, clearly permissible to have recourse to it as an aid to
construing the enacting provisions. The Preamble is not, however, of the
same weight as an aid to construction of a section of the Act as are
other relevant enacting words to be found elsewhere in the Act or even
in related Acts. There may be no exact correspondence between
preamble and enactment, and the enactment may go beyond, or it may
fall short of the indications that may be gathered from the preamble.
Again, the preamble cannot be of much or any assistance in construing
provisions which embody qualifications or exceptions from the
operation of the general purpose of the Act. It is only when it conveys a
clear and definite meaning in comparison with relatively obscure or
indefinite enacting words that the preamble may legitimately prevail.

72. It was further observed in Prince Ernest of Hanover (supra) that the
Courts are concerned with the practical business of deciding a lis, and
when the plaintiff puts forward one construction of an enactment and the
defendant another, it is the Court‟s business in any case of some

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 27 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
difficulty, after informing itself of what I have called the legal and factual
context including the preamble, to consider in the light of this knowledge
whether the enacting words admit of both the rival constructions put
forward. If they admit of only one construction, that construction will
receive effect even if it is inconsistent with the Preamble, but if the
enacting words are capable of either of the constructions offered by the
parties, the construction which fits the preamble may be preferred.

73. In R. Venkataswami Naidu vs. Narasram Naraindas (1966) 1 SCR
110, it was observed that though a Preamble is a key to interpreting the
statute, it cannot restrict the enacting part of the statute when it is clear,
wide and unambiguous. While acknowledging that the Objective for the
legislation is illustrated in the Preamble, it was explained that the remedy
in the enacting part of a statute may extend beyond the cure of the evil as
stated in the Preamble.

74. Nothing prevents the Legislature from providing coparcenary rights
to a daughter on the same footing as a son in a manner that is beyond the
wordings of the Preamble of the Act, 1956. Rather there is not even a
scintilla of ambiguity in the words of Section 6 of the Act, 1956 as they
clearly state that a daughter of a coparcener shall by birth become a
coparcener in her own right in the same manner as a son and any
reference to a Hindu Mitakshara Coparcener shall be deemed to include
a reference to a daughter of a coparcener. The explicit language of
Section 6 of the Amendment Act, 2005 makes it abundantly clear that
though the reference in the Preamble may be to inheritance, but

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 28 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
conferring "same" rights would include all other rights that a coparcener
has, which includes a right to be a Karta.

Statement of Objects and Reasons of Act (39 of 2005): -

75. Further, the Statement of Objects and Reasons of Act (39 of 2005)
apropos Section 6 perspicuously states that the provision has been
enacted to render social justice to women by removing the discrimination
in coparcenary ownership. The Statement of Objects reads as under: -

"2. Section 6 of the Act deals with devolution of interest
of a male Hindu in coparcenary property and recognises
the rule of devolution by survivorship among the
members of the coparcenary. The retention of the
Mitakshara coparcenary property without including the
females in it means that the females cannot inherit in
ancestral property as their male counterparts do. The
law by excluding the daughter from participating in the
coparcenary ownership not only contributes to her
discrimination on the ground of gender but also has led
to oppression and negation of her fundamental right of
equality guaranteed by the Constitution having regard
to the need to render social justice to women, the States
of Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka and
Maharashtra have made necessary changes in the law
giving equal right to daughters in Hindu Mitakshara
coparcenary property. The Kerala Legislature has
enacted the Kerala Joint Hindu Family System
(Abolition) Act, 1975."

76. We thus, observe that Section 6 of the Act, 1956 in clear and
unambiguous words, confers equal rights as a coparcener to a daughter as
well as the son. The dichotomy of status of coparcener and its necessary

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 29 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
incidents in conferring differential rights to son and daughter, hence stand
addressed, giving equal rights to both.

Whether recognition of a daughter as a Coparcener necessarily entitles
her to be a Karta: -

77. The appellant‟s entire arguments are premised essentially on the
ground that the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 was enacted to amend and
codify the law relating to intestate succession of property amongst Hindus
and in no manner tinkers with the customary Hindu law in regard to Karta
and his obligations which are specifically protected and preserved by
virtue of Section 4 of the Act, 1956.

78. The concept of coparcenary is derived from the joint ownership of
a common pool of assets held by a family and the necessary corollary was
that who owns the property, would have a right to manage it. When under
the traditional Hindu law, the woman was not entitled to coparcenary
property; resultantly, she could not assume the position of Karta.
However, the Amendment to Section 6 of the Act, 1956 redefines the
meaning of coparcenary as understood under the traditional Hindu Law,
which is no longer limited to devolution of interest in the coparcenary
property alone but encompasses all other incidents of a Coparcener,
including the right to be a Karta. To say that a woman can be a
coparcener but not a Karta, would be giving an interpretation which
would not only be anomalous but also against the stated Object of
introduction of Amendment.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 30 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
79. We also find support to this conclusion from Mulla on Hindu Law,
20th Edition-Volume II at Pages 234-235 which succinctly expresses the
most logical interpretation of the Amendment Act, 2005 as under:

"The Hindu Succession Act has been amended by the Hindu
Succession (Amendment) Act 2005. As a result of the
amendment daughters have been conferred equal status as
that of the sons in a Mitakshara coparcenary. It appears
that with the inclusion of daughters of a coparcener with
equal rights as those of sons, the ascension of a daughter
as Karta or Manager can no longer be ruled out. This
would have a lover be dependent on various factors, such as
the presence of other meals in the family, and the seniority
of the daughter qua such male coparceners. In the humble
opinion of the author, if therefore, there is a male
coparcener capable of acting as Karta, he would become
the Karta. If however, the daughter is senior to such male
coparcener, the daughter would become the Karta, unless
she expresses a desire not to act as such."
80. The appellant has placed reliance on Shreya Vidyarthi vs. Ashok
Vidyarthi (supra) to contend that a woman, even if is recognized as a
coparcener, cannot assume the status of Karta. In the said case, the rights
of a Widow of a Coparcener were under consideration, who was held not
entitled to be the Karta. The reason for disentitlement of a widow from
becoming the Karta of the HUF of her husband‟s family stems from the
principle that a wife only becomes a member of her husband‟s HUF upon
marriage, and not a Coparcener. This settled position, however, has to be
contradistinguished with the rights bestowed under the amended Section 6
as the said Amendment pertains to the daughter of a Coparcener as

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 31 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
opposed to the spouse. Thus, the reliance on Shreya Vidyarthi vs. Ashok
Vidyarthi (supra) is misplaced and is of no assistance to the appellant.

81. We thus, concur with the observations of learned Single Judge that
Section 4 of the Act, 1956 cannot be invoked artificially to prevent what
has been expressly done by the Legislature. To give any other
interpretation to deny the right of a woman to be a Coparcener and
consequently a Karta, would strike at the very Object of giving the
woman an equal right to property as a man. The right to manage the
property is incidental to ownership, and it is absurd to claim that the
owner of an estate is curtailed from the right to manage it.

ISSUE NO. 6: -

"Assuming existence of a D.R. Gupta and Sons HUF,
whether the plaintiff can be considered to be an integral
part of the HUF, particularly after her marriage in 1977,
and whether the plaintiff has ever participated in the affairs
of the HUF as a coparcener, and its effect? (OPP)"

82. The appellant claims that the learned Single Judge failed to
appreciate a significant aspect that performance of spiritual and
managerial duties is by the Karta of the HUF which respondent No. 1
being a female, cannot perform. Thus, it has to be accepted that only the
appellant, being the eldest male coparcener, is eligible to become the
Karta of the "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF".

83. This argument raises a fundamental question of the necessary
competency of the woman to perform the religious and familial
obligations of a Karta in the backdrop of Mitakshara Law.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 32 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
Spiritual efficacy of a female Coparcener: -

84. Their Lordships of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in
Surendranath v. Musammat Heeramonee,12 M. I. A. 81 observed that in
the Hindu Law there is so close a connection between their religion and
the succession to property that the preferable right to perform the shradha
is commonly viewed as governing also the preferable right to succession
of property as a general rule.

85. In the case of Katama Natchivar vs. Raja of Sivaganga, 9 M.I. A.,
610, the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council enunciated that there are
two leading rules of Inheritance that are founded on the religious duty and
superior efficacy of oblations and sacrifice and that of survivorship, in the
Hindu Law. When the latter rule cannot apply, the former must be
resorted to.

86. There are two systems of inheritance according to Hindu Law: (1)
The Mitakshara system, and (2) The Dayabhaga system. The Dayabhaga
system prevails in Bengal, while the Mitakshara system prevails in other
parts of India. Both the systems are based upon the text of Manu that "to
the nearest Sapinda the inheritance next belongs; after them, the
Sakulyas, the preceptor of the Vedas, or a pupil". The differences
between the two systems arise from the fact that while the doctrine of
religious efficacy is the guiding principle under Dayabhaga School, there
is no such definite guiding principle under the Mitakshara School.

87. Dayabhaga system brings out a different explanation to the texts of
Manu. It states that the closest Sapinda is the one who can make an
offering to the ancestors' souls and thus, the doctrine of religious efficacy

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 33 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
or spiritual benefit is the guiding principle of inheritance under the
Dayabhaga Law. It may sound incongruent to say but the logic of this
principle is that according to the traditional principles of Hindu Law,
property is regarded as the means of paying a man's funeral expenses,
thus the right of inheritance is wholly regulated with reference to the
spiritual benefits to be conferred on the deceased.

88. Mitakshara interprets Sapinda as the nearest in blood that will be
the heir. The Mitakshara system is, therefore, based on consanguinity or
proximity of blood relationship. The fundamental principle of Mitakshara
Law of Succession is propinquity, with the crucial exception that no
cognate aside from a daughter's son may succeed an agnate in
preference. The principle of spiritual benefit does not find mention in the
Mitakshara Law for determining the order of succession. Among Bhinna
Gotraja Sapinda, the test is propinquity, i.e., the nearness in blood and
agnates are preferred to cognates. Mitakshara thus, recognises two modes
of devolution of property, namely, survivorship and succession. The rules
of survivorship apply to joint family property, and the rules of succession
apply to property held in absolute severalty by the last owner.

89. Mulla explains the right to inheritance under the Mitakshara School
of Law as under: -

"Though under the Mitakshara the right to inherit does
not arise from the right to offer oblation, the test to be
applied when a question of preference arises in the case
of sagotra sapindas, is the capacity to offer oblation, but,
in the case of bhinna gotra sapindas, „primary test‟ is
„propinquity of blood‟ and, when the degree of blood

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 34 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
relationship furnishes no certain guide,‟ best is the
capacity for conferring spiritual benefit."

90. From the above discussion, we may conclude that the spiritual
efficiency is an indispensable requirement under the Dayabhaga Law;
however, the same cannot be presumed under Mitakshara law. It is amply
clear from the above that the spiritual duties performed by a Karta of an
HUF governed by Mitakshara law was only coincidental to the fact that
only male descendants were entitled to become coparceners in the past.
Thus, with the amendment in law conferring daughters with coparcenary
rights, spiritual efficiency or the ability to perform certain rituals cannot
become a prerequisite qualification for becoming a Karta of an HUF
governed by Mitakshara law.

91. Spiritual efficiency comes under consideration only when the
question of preference arises. In the present case, the question of
preference is obviated by the overt seniority by age of respondent No.1 in
comparison to the appellant.

Non-Participation in the Affairs of the Family after Marriage: -

92. The appellant also claims that respondent No.1 has not been
involved in the management of the HUF properties post her marriage in
1969. It was Manu Gupta/appellant who took charge of managing the
properties and filing of Income Tax Returns for the same after the demise
of Late Shri R.N. Gupta on 14.02.2006. Thus, respondent No.1 has no
right to claim Kartaship. In this regard it is apposite to first examine
whether the position of Karta is conferred on a person who actually

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 35 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
performs all the managerial duties or whether it is a position that is
conferred by law.

93. The Apex Court in Union Of India vs. Sree Ram Bohra & Ors.
(1965) 2 SCR 830, dealt with a peculiar question of whether an HUF can
have two Kartas at the same time. The business activities in the said HUF
were managed by two Coparceners who represented themselves as the
Karta of the HUF in a Suit. While emphasising that an HUF cannot have
two Kartas at the same time, it was concluded that any member of a
family can act as a manager to carry on business etc on behalf of the
family. This, however, does not mean that such representatives become
the Karta(s) of the HUF. Thus, their authority to manage the HUF and
represent it in legal matters is derived from the authority given by the
family or the Karta and not from any principle of Hindu Law. The Court
relied on the judgement of Bhagwan Dayal vs. Reoti Devi (1962) 3 SCR
440 wherein it was observed as under: -

"The legal position may be stated thus: Coparcenary is a
creature of Hindu law and cannot be created by
agreement of parties except in the case of reunion.
....Ordinarily the manager, or by consent, express or
implied, of the members of the family, any other
member or members can carry on business or acquire
property. subject to the limitations laid down by the said
law, for or on behalf of the family."

94. Punjab and Haryana High Court in Madan Mohan vs. Balkishan
Das 1964 SCC OnLine Punj 256, stated that in some exceptional cases,
the Karta need not be the eldest Coparcener. Be that as it may, a

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 36 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
managing member does not become a Karta merely because he was
managing the properties of the HUF on behalf of its members.

95. In a similar vein, in Sunderlal Nanalal (HUF) vs. Commissioner of
Income-Tax, Gujarat-II, Ahmedabad 1983 SCC OnLine Guj 198, it was
observed that the Karta of the HUF, due to his old age and indifferent
health, can assign the role of managing the business to a Coparcener
through an agreement on behalf of the family.

96. From the aforesaid rulings, we may observe that while a HUF
cannot have two Kartas, it being a legal entitlement of the eldest member
of an HUF, but the duty of management can be performed by another
Coparcener in given circumstances. This relegation of managerial
responsibility does take away the legal title of a Karta, unless it is
renounced by the person legally entitled to be a Karta.

97. This court thus, concludes that being a Karta is conferment of legal
status which includes right to manage the HUF properties and even if the
appellant represented himself as Karta in official correspondence on
behalf of HUF to manage the property, it does not take away the legal
right of the eldest member of the Coparcener of the family, even if she is
a woman, to stake a claim to be a Karta.

Societal stereotypes - Social acceptance: -

98. The appellant has come up with myriad hypotheses justifying why
it would be incorrect for a woman to become a Karta from the societal
standpoint.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 37 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
99. Traditionally, the eldest male commanded the respect and
obedience of the family due to the power proffered upon them. The only
hindrance to a female Karta commanding the same respect today is the
reluctance of a family to accept the social and cultural change. Many a
times, a change or amendment in law becomes a trigger to stimulate
social change as opined in Badshah vs. Urmila Badshah Godse & Anr.
(2014) 1 SCC 188.

100. The Law Commission of India in its 174th Report on Property
Rights of Women: Proposed reforms under the Hindu Law (2000) had
noticed the societal uneasiness with the idea of a woman assuming the
role of a Karta at a time when the State Amendment Acts began to
recognise the interest of a daughter in the coparcenary:-

"3.2.12 The HSA of 1956 dithered in not abolishing the
very concept of coparcenary which the Act should have
done. But the Hindu Succession (State Amendment)
Acts have conferred upon the daughter of a
coparcener, the right to become a coparcener like a
son which may affect the brother-sister relationship. It
further appears that even where daughters have been
made coparceners there is still a reluctance to making
her a Karta as the general male view is that she is
incapable of managing the properties or running the
business and is generally susceptible to the influence
of her husband and his family, if married. This seems
to be patently unfair as women are proving themselves
equal to any task and if women are influenced by
their husbands and their families, men are no less
influenced by their wives and their families."

101. Experience has shown that any culture or practice that is ingrained
in the society is bound to face some apprehension and resistance by the

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 38 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
society when systemic changes are made to it. But with passage of time it
becomes a tool of social change. The amendment to Section 6 of the Act,
1956 owes its provenance to the right to equality guaranteed under Article
14 of the Constitution of India. Such societal displeasure was also
witnessed in the cases of Navtej Singh Johar and Ors. vs. Union of India,
Ministry of Law and Justice, (2018) 1 SCC 791; K.S. Puttaswamy and
Anr. vs. Union of India and Ors, (2017) 10 SCC 1 where the test of
popular acceptance was applied to hold that the guarantee of
constitutional rights does not depend upon their exercise being favourably
regarded by majoritarian opinion. The test of popular acceptance does not
furnish a valid basis to disregard statutory rights that are conferred with
the sanctity of constitutional protection.

102. Further, the rights of the members in a coparcenary remain
unaffected even when a female coparcener acts as its Karta as
Coparceners continue to enjoy the same entitlements and interests which
they otherwise have; their rights as coparcener do not get impinged in any
manner. If there arises any scepticism about the skills, efficiency,
sincerity or ability of female Coparceners to act as the Karta or being
influenced by her in-laws, the other Coparceners have adequate remedies
to seek for a partition or impeach any wrongful alienation of property
made by the Karta.

103. Moreover, contention that the husband of a female Karta would
have an indirect control over the activities of the HUF of her father‟s
family is only a parochial mindset which even the legislature had
diligently attempted to oust through Section 14 of the Act, 1956 to accord

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 39 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
women with the long overdue right to be the absolute owner of her
property. If a woman is proscribed from becoming a Karta in view of this
reasoning as cited by the appellant, it will only render the legislative
endeavour to give rights in immovable properties to women through
Section 14 of the Act,1956 as a mere mirage. Ergo, a woman who has
absolute ownership in a property cannot be denied a right to manage it on
the warped reasoning that she may get influenced by her in-laws. Thus,
societal apprehension and reluctance can never truncate legislative
enactments to do away with patriarchal discrimination.

104. We, therefore, conclude that neither the Legislature nor the
traditional Hindu Law in any way limits the right of a woman to be a
Karta. Also, societal perceptions cannot be a reason to deny the rights
expressly conferred by Legislature. There is no impediment in the
respondent No. 1 being the Karta of the HUF.

ISSUE NO. 4: -

"Whether the plaintiff is a member of D.R. Gupta and Sons
HUF? And if so, to what effect?" (OPP)

ISSUE NO. 7: -
"Assuming existence of D.R. Gupta and Sons HUF, whether the
plaintiff is a coparcener of and legally entitled to be the Karta?"(OPP)
105. It is the case of the respondent Nos. 9 and 10 that respondent No. 1
was not the daughter of a surviving Coparcener when the Amendment Act

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 40 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
of 2006 came into force as her father has expired before the
commencement of the Amendment Act of 2005.

106. According to the finding in Prakash and Ors. vs. Phulvati (supra),
living daughters of living Coparceners as on 09.09.2005 are entitled to the
rights under the substituted Section 6, regardless of when such daughters
are born. Howbeit, a three-Judge Bench of the Apex Court in the land
mark case of Vineeta Sharma (supra) concluded that the Court in Prakash
and Ors. (supra) did not bring attention to the issue of how a coparcenary
is formed. It is not required for a previous Coparcener to be alive in order
to form a coparcenary or to become a coparcener; what matters is birth
within the degrees of the coparcenary to which it extends. The mode of
succession, not the process of forming a coparcenary, is one of survival.

107. The Apex Court thus, clarified the rights of a daughter as a
Coparcener under the amended Section 6 of the Act, 1956 and concluded
that it is not necessary that the father of the daughter should be alive on
the date of the amendment.

108. The Apex Court in Vineeta Sharma (supra) further observed that
the amended provision of Section 6(1) of the Act, 1956 provides that on
and from the date of Amendment, the daughter is conferred the right of
coparcenary „in her own right‟ and „in the same manner as a son‟. The
right of Coparcener is by birth, and the rights are given in the same
manner with the incidents of coparcenary as that of a son. Hence, as this
right is acquired by way of birth, the same is unobstructive in nature
as long as the birth is within the degrees of coparcenary. It is thus,
irrelevant that a coparcener whose daughter is conferred with the rights is

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 41 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
alive or not as the right to be a Coparcener is independent of the existence
of the father, making respondent No.1 the eldest surviving Coparcener.

109. Thus, the right of the daughter of a Coparcener to enjoy the status
of a Coparcener from the commencement of the Hindu Succession
(Amendment) Act, 2005 cannot hinge upon the life span of her father.
Such a distinction can certainly not sustain the test of intelligible
differentia that was sought to be addressed through the Amendment.

110. The same contention was initially raised by the appellant as well,
however, it was withdrawn by conceding to the coparcenary right of a
woman in light of the holding in Vineeta Sharma (supra).

111. We thus, agree with the observations of learned Single Judge that
merely because father of respondent No.1 had died before the
introduction of the Amendment Act, 2005 her right to be a Karta is not
lost.

ISSUE NO. 3: -

"Whether there exists any coparcenary property or HUF at all?
OPP"
ISSUE NO. 5
"Whether the interest of the plaintiff separated upon the
demise of her father Sh. K.M. Gupta in 1984?" (OPD)

112. The learned Single Judge had referred to a Family Settlement dated
01.04.1999 Ex PW1/5 to observe that respondent No. 1 was a party to the
said Family Settlement of 1999 as she was an acknowledged Coparcener
being the daughter of Kishan Mohan Gupta, to conclude this issue in
favour of respondent No.1.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 42 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
113. While respondent No. 1, as a matter of right would be a Coparcener
by birth, this right hinges upon the existence and continuance of the D.R.
Gupta HUF when the Amendment Act of 2005 came into effect. The
proviso to Section 6(1) of the Act lucidly provides that nothing contained
in this sub-section shall affect or invalidate any disposition or alienation
including any partition or testamentary disposition of property which had
taken place before the 20th day of December, 2004.

114. The Appellant assails and challenges the coparcenary right of
respondent No. 1 in light of her Written Statement in another Suit
(Partition Suit CS(OS) 142/2008 filed by respondent Nos. 9 and 10)
where it was asserted by her that the suit property had already been
partitioned in 1999. Thus, respondent No.1 cannot claim to be a Karta
when the coparcenary itself has ceased to exist.

115. Admittedly, Shri D.R. Gupta, the common ancestor of all the
parties to the Suit, had constituted a "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF" on
05.01.1963 of which his five sons were the Coparceners. Shri D.R. Gupta
had drawn both moveable and immoveable properties into a common
hotchpotch to be owned by the HUF. The HUF was assessed to Income
Tax and was allotted PAN No. AAA HD 4230 M. Further, it is not in
dispute that all the sons of Shri D.R. Gupta had expired, the last being
Shri R.N. Gupta who expired on 14.02.2006.

116. The essential question is whether the HUF stood dissolved upon
the demise of Shri D.R. Gupta on 02.09.1977 or continued even after
the demise of his five sons.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 43 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
117. The appellant DW1/Manu Gupta had deposed that "D.R. Gupta &
Sons HUF" ceased to exist in the year 1971 on the demise of Shri D.R.
Gupta and thus, the question of anyone being the Karta of this HUF does
not survive. PW3/N.V. Satyanarayan, Defence Estate Officer, Delhi
Circle, Delhi produced the copy of the Letter dated 01.06.1985
Ex. PW3/A addressed to Smt. Shanta K Mohan, wife of Shri Krishan
Mohan (father of the respondent No. 1), in regard to the mutation of the
suit property. The said letter is reproduced as under: -

" No: 3/220-F/III/180
DEFENCE ESTATES OFFICE, DELHI CIRCLE,
DELHI CANTONMENT DATED 01, Jun, 1985.

To
Mrs. Shanta K. Mohan W/O
Late Shri Krishan Mohan
18, Anand Lok, NEW DELHI.

SUBJECT : MITIGATION IN THE NAME OF
SUCCESSOR OF LATE Shri Krishan Mohan
(Karta) (HUF).

In r/o No. 4, University Road, Delhi.

Reference your affidavit dated 13.8.1984
received in this office on 24thAugust, 1984 under
your letter dated 16/21.8.1984.

2. It is to inform you that necessary entries an
requested under your letter cited above have been
effected in the record of this office as successors of
Late Shri Krishan Mohan.

(i) ShrimatiShanta K. Mohan

(ii) Smt. SuzataSharma

(iii) Smt. Radhika Seth

3. This is for your information and record.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 44 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
Sd/-

DEFENCE ESTATES OFFICER, DELHI CIRCLE.

(A.P. SINGH)"

118. It is evident from the bare perusal of the aforesaid Letter that Smt.
Shanta K. Mohan, Smt. Sujata Sharma and Smt. Radhika Seth, the legal
heirs of Late Krishan Mohan Gupta in terms of their Affidavit dated
13.08.1984, were added as the owners and the property was mutated in
the joint name of aforesaid three legal heirs of Late Shri Krishan Mohan
Gupta. The Mutation Letter dated 01.06.1985 Ex PW3/A shows that the
two daughters of Late Shri Krishan Mohan Gupta had also been entered in
the records as joint owners. This was neither necessary nor permissible as
in 1971 daughters were not recognised as Coparceners. Had the HUF
been continuing after the demise of Late Shri D.R. Gupta on 01.10.1971,
such inclusion of daughters in the mutation would have never taken place.
119. The second document of relevance is Letter dated 05.08.2003
Ex. PW3/B produced by PW3 addressed to Shri R.N. Gupta (Karta of the
HUF then) by the Defence Estates Office which also deals with mutation
of the suit property in the name of legal heirs of late Shri J.N Gupta, Late
Shri B.N. Gupta and Late Shri M.N. Gupta. The letter declared all the
legal heirs as stated above as joint owners of the suit property through its
Karta, Late Shri R.N. Gupta.
120. The aforesaid two documents reveal that all the respective legal
heirs of the four deceased brothers had been individually and separately
entered in the records as joint owners. Though the property was declared
as HUF property, but all the legal heirs, including the girls were made
RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 45 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
joint owners. Had there been an HUF continuing after the demise of
Late Shri D.R. Gupta, the property need not have been mutated in
the name of daughters as they were not Coparceners according to the
law existing then. The very fact that all the legal heirs from time to time
have been recorded as joint owners on demise of their father in the
mutation records of the suit property, leads to an inference that there
was no HUF that continued after the demise of Late Shri D.R. Gupta
and the properties of the HUF became the joint property of the legal
heirs of Shri. D.R. Gupta.
121. Respondent No. 1 Sujata Sharma has asserted that a partial
partition of moveable assets took place on 26.03.1977 in respect of
deposits and shares in Motor and General Finance Limited. There is no
denial that pursuant to this partial partition, each coparcener became
entitled to receive from the HUF, a sum of Rs. 28,000/- from the deposits
of Motor and General Finance Limited held by HUF and further each was
to get 1000 equity shares of the Motor General and Finance Limited as
their respective share while the other properties continued to remain in the
HUF. The Notice of Partial Partition as required under Section 171 of the
Income Tax Act, 1961 was also agreed to be sent.
122. Another significant fact which was stated and which essentially has
not been disputed by all the parties, except Smt. Meera Sawhney and Smt.
Gargi Gupta (respondent Nos. 9 and 10 who are the two legal heirs of
Late Shri B.N. Gupta), is a Family Settlement of 01.04.1999 Ex.PW1/5
which admittedly has the signatures of four sons of the deceased Shri
D.R. Gupta (Shri M.N. Gupta, Shri R.N. Gupta, Shri B.N. Gupta, Shri

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 46 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
J.N. Gupta) and of respondent No. 1/Sujata Sharma, her sister Smt.
Radhika Seth and their mother, Smt. Shanta K. Mohan being the legal
heirs of late Shri Krishan Mohan (son of Shri D.R. Gupta) who had died
on 18.02.1984.
123. According to this Memorandum of Family Settlement, an oral
partition had taken place between all the parties on 18.01.1999 and the
same was recorded in the Memorandum of Settlement dated 01.04.1999.
In the said Memorandum, it was clearly stipulated as under: -
"2. The parties hereto confirm and declare that the oral
family settlement dated 18.1.1999 was arrived at on the
following terms.
2.1 The parties acknowledge and confirmed that that
the parties hereto are the members of the Hindu
Undivided Family D.R. Gupta & Sons (HUF) and each
having share in the movable and immovable properties
presently owned by the Hindu Undivided Family as
under:
a) Shri Krishan Mohan Gupta (the eldest son of late
Shri D.R. Gupta, who died on 17th Feb. 1984 and is
survived by his wife Smt. Shanta K Mohan and Mrs.
Sujata Sharma & Mrs. Radhika Seth, daughter, heirs
to the party of the "First Party" 1/5th share.
b) Shri Mahendra Nath Gupta as Karta (party of the
"Second Part) 1/5th share.
c) Mr. Ravinder Nath Gupta (party of the Third")
1/5th share.
d) Shri Bhupinder Nath Gupta (party of the "Fourth")
1/5th share.
e) Mr. Jitender Nath Gupta (party of the "Fifth Part")
1/5th share.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 47 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
2.2 The parties acknowledge and confirm that the
Hindu Undivided Family owns and possesses the
following movable and immovable properties.

a) Bunglow No. 4 University Road, Delhi

b) Share of Motor & General Finance Ltd.

(4309Share)

c) Bank account of Hindu Undivided Family D.R.
Gupta & Sons (HUF) with Bank of India. Asaf Ali
Road, New Delhi.

d) Bank account with Vijiya Bank, Ansari Road, New
Delhi

e) Deposit with the Motor & General Finance Ltd. of
Rs. 6,400/-.

2.3 The parties effected partition of Hindu Undivided
Family D.r. Gupta & Sons (HUF) and that the parties
hereto being the members of the said Hindu Undivided
Family were entitled to and were owners of the
movable and immovable properties of the said Hindu
Undivided Family mentioned in para 2.2 above to the
extent as under:

a) Shri Krishan Mohan Gupta (The eldest son of late
Shri D.R. Gupta, who died on 17th Feb. 1984) and is
survived by his wife Smt. Shanta K Mohan and Mrs.
Sujata Sharma & Mrs. Radhika Seth, daughter, heirs
to the party of the "First Part". 1/5th Share.
b) Shri Mahendra Nath Gupta (as karta of the "Second
Party"). 1/5th Share.
c) Mr. Ravinder Nath Gupta (party of the "Third
Part"). 1/5th Share.
d) Mr. Bhupinder Nath Gupta (Party of the "Fourth
Part"). 1/5th Share.
e) Mr. Jitender Nath Gupta (Party of the "Fifth Part").
1/5th Share.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 48 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
7. No one party or parties hereto shall be entitled to bind the
other parties hereto by his acts or deed with respect to the
affairs of the said business.

8. It has been further agreed between the parties that the
immovable property No. 4 University Road, Delhi, after the
partition, if any, of the HUF, and recording of this family
settlement, will continue to remain in the name of D.R.
Gupta & Sons, HUF before the Revenue
Authority/competent Authority."

124. As is already discussed in detail, all the family members have
admitted this document of Memorandum of Settlement dated 01.04.1999
Ex. PW1/5. Pertinently, even respondent Nos. 9 and 10 have not disputed
the execution of the document in this Suit, but only assail its validity.

125. It is the appellant‟s assertion that respondent No. 1 has taken
contradictory stance with respect of the existence of the HUF. However,
we find that respondent No.1, in her Written Statement in CS(OS)
142/2008 has merely averred that a partition of the HUF by determining
the share of each branch took place prior to the Amendment Act of 2005
and thus, such a prior partition cannot be reopened. This statement is
nothing but in conformity with the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act,
2005 which came into effect on 09.09.2005. Section 6 (5) of the Amended
Act, perspicuously explains that the provision will be inapplicable in
cases where a partition had been effected before 20.12.2004.

126. It has emerged from the evidence of the parties that the HUF
continued only for the purpose of dealing with the Revenue
Authority/Competent Authority. The relevant portion of the said Written
Statement reads as under: -

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 49 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
"6. ...However as per the Partition, the parties agreed
that the Immovable property 4, University Road, Delhi
will continue to remain in the name of D.R. Gupta & Sons
HUF before the Revenue Authority/Competent
Authority."
127. With respect to the Family Settlement, respondent No. 1 as PW1
had deposed as under: -

"Q. 25. How is the Family Settlement dated 1.4.1999 refer to
in your affidavit in evidence as Exhibit PW 1/5 (to which
there is an objection as to mode of proof) relevant to the
question of Karta?
A. I have brought the original of Exhibit PW1/5 (shown to the
Commissioner and returned). This document is of partition
of HUF. It is a family settlement. It gives a share of all the
families and we have to deal with certain authorities such
as Defence Estates and other authorities for which we
require a Karta. This is the evidence."

128. The appellant as DW1 also made certain significant admissions. On
being asked who was the Karta of Late Shri D.R. Gupta, HUF after the
death of Late Shri D.R. Gupta, he replied that it was Shri Krishan Mohan
Gupta. He also clarified that "after the death of Shri Krishan Mohan
Gupta, there was no Karta as such but for the Military Defence Estate
Office, the information regarding the passing away of Mr. Krishan
Mohan Gupta was given by Mahender Nath Gupta, holding himself to be
the Karta of HUF. After Mr. Mahender Nath Gupta, there was no Karta
as such but for the Military Defence Estate Office, the information
regarding the passing away of Mahender Nath Gupta, was given by Mr.
Ravinder Nath Gupta".

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 50 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
129. DW1/Manu Gupta (appellant herein) thereafter deposed that earlier
Income Tax Returns were being filed, but the same have not been filed
now for the last many years. On being asked specifically if he was a
Coparcener of "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF", DW1 stated that "assuming
the HUF exists, I am Coparcener otherwise I am member of the Joint
Family".

130. DW1/Manu Gupta further deposed that like the members before
him who informed the Defence Estate Office about the passing away of
previous Karta to the Estate Office as the Karta of the family, he also
informed the said Office. He even informed the Motor and General
Finance Limited Company where the HUF holds some shares to change
the name of the authorised signatory from that of Mr. R.N. Gupta to his
name.

131. DW1/Manu Gupta also deposed that the House Tax for the suit
property was paid upto 2007, but he was not aware thereafter. The system
of paying the house tax was that all the five branches of the family used to
share equal payment of house tax.

132. From these significant admissions of the appellant/DW1 coupled
with the letters produced by PW3/ N.V. Satyanarayan, Defence Estate
Officer in regard to the mutation of the property in the name of all the
legal heirs of respective sons of Late Shri D.R. Gupta, the irresistible
conclusion that can be drawn is that "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF" came to
an end on the demise of Shri D.R. Gupta and all his sons as five branches
became equally entitled to their respective share and consequently, all
were mutated as the owners of the suit property. Thus, no HUF was

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 51 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
continued after 1977, but the senior most male member was representing
himself for and on behalf of all the owners by reflecting himself as a
Karta of "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF", merely for the purpose of
nomenclature and as the authorised representative of all the family
members.

133. Now, coming to the Memorandum of Settlement dated 01.04.1999
Ex. PW1/5, all the parties have admitted to the execution of this
document, though they have interpreted it differently and have raised
contradictory claims.

134. First and foremost, it is stated in the Memorandum of Settlement
that an oral partition took place on 18.01.1999. The validity of an oral
partition has been recognised in the case of Kale vs. Director of
Consolidation 118 (1976) 3 SCC 119, the Hon‟ble Apex Court explained
how the family settlement is effected which reads as under: -

"10. In other words to put the binding effect and the
essentials of a family settlement in a concretised form, the
matter may be reduced into the form of the following
propositions:
(1) The family settlement must be a bona fide one so
as to resolve family disputes and rival claims by a
fair and equitable division or allotment of
properties between the various members of the
family;
(2) The said settlement must be voluntary and
should not be induced by fraud, coercion or undue
influence;
(3) The family arrangement may be even oral in
which case no registration is necessary;

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 52 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
(4) It is well settled that registration would be
necessary only if the terms of the family
arrangement are reduced into writing. Here also, a
distinction should be made between a document
containing the terms and recitals of a family
arrangement made **under the document** and a
mere memorandum prepared after the family
arrangement had already been made either for the
purpose of the record or for information of the
court for making necessary mutation. In such a
case the memorandum itself does not create or
extinguish any rights in immovable properties and
therefore does not fall within the mischief of
Section 17(2)of the Registration Act and is,
therefore, not compulsorily registrable;
(5) The members who may be parties to the family
arrangement must have some antecedent title, claim
or interest even a possible claim in the property
which is acknowledged by the parties to the
settlement. Even if one of the parties to the
settlement has no title but under the arrangement
the other party relinquishes all its claims or titles in
favour of such a person and acknowledges him to be
the sole owner, then the antecedent title must be
assumed and the family arrangement will be upheld
and the courts will find no difficulty in giving assent
to the same;
(6) Even if bona fide disputes, present or possible,
which may not involve legal claims are settled by a
bona fide family arrangement which is fair and
equitable the family arrangement is final and
binding on the parties to the settlement."

135. The second aspect is the registration of the Memorandum of
Settlement dated 01.04.1999 which recorded the Oral Settlement dated
18.01.1999. In Teg Bahadur Bhujil vs. Debi Singh Bhujil AIR 1966 SC

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 53 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
292, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed that a family arrangement can
also be arrived at orally and registration would not be required only if its
terms may be recorded in writing as a memorandum of what has been
agreed upon between the parties. The memorandum need not be prepared
for the purpose of being used as a document on which future title of the
parties be founded. It is usually prepared as a record of what has been
agreed upon so that there is no hazy notion about it in future.

136. In Kalwa Devadattam vs. Union of India AIR 1994 SC 880, while
endorsing that an oral partition was permissible, the Hon‟ble Apex Court
observed that the burden of proof remained on the person who asserted
such partition. The separate occupation of portions, division of the income
of the joint property, defining of shares of the joint property in the
revenue or land registration records, mutual transactions could be the
factors which may become significant to prove an oral agreement as
observed in Bhagwani Kunwar vs. Mohan Singh AIR 1925 PC 132 and
Digambar Adhar Patil vs. Devram Girdhar Patil AIR 1995 SC 1728.

137. It is also pertinent to note that the Memorandum of Family
Settlement was only signed by the first stirpe of the coparcenary and not
by all its coparceners at that point in time. Under Hindu Law, though all
the Coparceners have an undivided share in the properties belonging to
the HUF, however, this principle of undivided ownership of each
coparcener is not applied when the members of the HUF decide to effect a
partition. The Madras High Court in A.M. Narayana Sah vs. A. Sankar
Sah 1929 SCC OnLine Mad 53 referred to Mayne on Hindu Law, Page
346, Paragraph 270, which reads as under: -

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 54 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
"It is common to say that in an undivided family each
member transmits to his issue his own share in the joint
property, and that such issue takes per capita inter se,
but per stirpes as regards the issue of other members.
But it must always be remembered that this is only a
statement of what would be their rights on a partition.
Until a partition all their rights consist merely in a
common enjoyment of the common property, to which is
further added the right of male issue to forbid alienations,
made by their direct ancestors"

138. Thus, when the partition of an HUF takes place, the shares are
divided amongst each branch of the HUF. However, this division amongst
branches does not lead to the creation of a separate coparcenary in each
branch; rather the share so allotted to a branch is equally divided amongst
all its leaves (members).

139. In the present case, the shares in the Family Settlement of 1999 has
been determined as 1/5 per stirpe (which included the legal heirs of Late
Shri K.M. Gupta, Shri M.N. Gupta, R.N. Gupta, Shri J.N. Gupta), thus
constituting a division of their respective shares as per Hindu Law.

140. In this context, the decision of the Privy Council in Appovier vs.
Rama Subba Aiyan 11 M.I.A. 75 (1866) described the manner in which
severance of status of HUF may take place which reads as under: -

"According to the true notion of an undivided family in Hindoo
law, no individual member of that family, whilst it remains
undivided, can prejudice of the joint and undivided property,
that he, that particular member, has a certain definite share. No
individual of an undivided family could go to the place of the
receipt of rent, and claim to take from the Collector or receiver
of the rents, a certain definite share. The proceeds of undivided
property must be brought, according to the theory of an

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 55 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
undivided family, to the common chest or purse, and then dealt
with according to the modes of enjoyment by the members of an
undivided family. But when the members of an undivided
family agree among themselves with regard to particular
property, that it shall thenceforth be the subject of ownership,
in certain defined shares, then the character of undivided
property and joint enjoyment is taken away from the subject-
matter so agreed to be dealt with; and in the estate, each
member has thenceforth a definite and certain share, which he
may claim the right to receive and to enjoy in severalty,
although the property itself has not been actually severed and
divided.
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx
Then, if there be a conversion of the joint tenancy of an
undivided family into a tenancy in common of the members of
that undivided family, the undivided family becomes a divided
family with reference to the property that is the subject of that
agreement, and that is a separation in interest and in right,
although not immediately followed by a de facto actual
division of the subject matter. This may at any time be claimed
by virtue of the separate right."

141. Thus, in the present case, it is established there was no continuation
of "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF" after the demise of Shri D. R. Gupta in the
year 1977 and the property got mutated in the name of all the legal heirs.
In furtherance of such severance of status, the also parties determined the
shares of each of the branch of the five brothers to be 1/5th as mentioned
in the Memorandum of Settlement. Thus, even though no partition by
metes and bounds took effect between the parties, a partition took
place leading to severance of status of the undivided family into a
divided family.

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 56 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
142. At this juncture, we may examine that an HUF that has albeit
ceased to exist under the Hindu Law, but may continue to be so recorded
as an HUF in the revenue or Income Tax records.

143. In Kalloomal Tapeswari Prasad (HUF), Kanpur vs. Commissioner
of Income Tax, Kanpur (1982) 1 SCC 447, after referring to Appovier
(supra), the Hon‟ble Apex Court concluded that Hindu law does not
require that the property, must in every case be partitioned by metes and
bounds or physically into different portions to complete a partition.
Disruption of status can be brought about by any of the modes (1) by a
father during his lifetime between himself and his sons by dividing
properties equally amongst them, (2) by agreement, or (3) by a suit or
arbitration. It is open to the parties to enjoy their share of property as
tenants-in-common in any manner known to law according to their desire.
However, Income Tax law introduces certain conditions of its own to
give effect to the partition under Section 171 of the Income Tax Act.
Section 171 postulates that until a claim is made under Section 171(2)
of the Income Tax Act that there has been a partition (total or
partial) of the HUF, it continues to exist under the Income Tax
records. Sub-Section 1 of Section 171 of the Income Tax Act contains a
deeming fiction that provides that a Hindu family hitherto cease as
undivided, shall be deemed for the purpose of the Income Tax Act to
continue to be a Hindu Undivided Family, except where and insofar as a
finding of partition has been recorded in respect of it under Section 171 of
the Income Tax Act. Such finding of partition can be recorded only where
the property admits to physical division which has taken place. Mere

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 57 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
physical division of the income without a physical division of the
property, cannot be treated as a partition.

144. Therefore, having concluded that the severance of status had taken
place in the year 1977 and that a partition of the suit property which was
till then in the nature of Joint Hindu property has also been effected by the
parties vide Memorandum of Family Settlement dated 01.04.1999, but it
has still not been partitioned by metes and bounds, but it would still
continue to be assessed as a Hindu Undivided property in the Government
records/Income Tax records and for that purpose one of the family
members has to represent himself on behalf of an HUF. This is exactly
what has been stated by the appellant in his testimony that it is only for
the purpose of communication with the Government authorities that the
suit property was being reflected in the name of "D.R. Gupta & Sons
HUF". Thus, the partition has already happened but the appellant had so
communicated on behalf of HUF as it had to be represented before the
Competent Authority till the partition actually takes place by metes and
bounds.

145. Lastly, we observe that the position of Karta is a legal entitlement
that has no bearings on the person who actually performs the managerial
functions. In the present case, though there is no express delegation by
respondent No.1 or other members on the appellant, the status of a Karta
and his acts of performing managerial functions do not confer him with
the title of Karta for the "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF".

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 58 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
Having held that the respondent No. 1 is entitled to be the Karta
under law, she is hereby declared as Karta of D.R. Gupta and Sons,
HUF.

ISSUE NO. 1: -

" Whether the Suit has been valued properly and proper court fee
has been paid thereon? OPP"
146. Respondent No.1/plaintiff has stated that she has valued the Suit for
the purpose of jurisdiction at over Rs. 1,00,00,000/- and the court fee
payable on the relief of declaration being fixed at Rs. 20/- which has been
paid.

147. The law in regard to the valuation for the purpose of court fee and
jurisdiction is well-settled. The party while the valuation for the purpose
of jurisdiction determines the forum where the Suit is to be filed i.e.,
whether before the District Court or the High Court, the valuation of the
Suit for the purpose of court fee is for the purpose of affixing the requisite
court fee.

148. We find that the respondent No. 1 has vaguely stated that the Suit
valuation is more than Rs. 1,00,00,000/-. The plaintiff/respondent No. 1
should have been specific in giving valuation for the purpose of
jurisdiction. Considering that the plaintiff has the discretion to value their
suit as held by the full bench of this Court in Smt. Sheila Devi vs. Kishan
Lal Kalra ILR (1974) 2 Del 491and as the trial has continued for over 18
years, we do not deem it appropriate to seek further clarification on this
aspect and hold the jurisdictional valuation as Rs. 1,00,00,000/-.

149. The next aspect is what should be the court fee payable on this
valuation. The declaratory Suits essentially deal with the status of a
RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 59 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
person or a property and, therefore, being an inherent right is not subject
to any valuation. Therefore, under the Court Fee Act, the minimum
valuation of the Suit for Declaration has been assessed as Rs. 200/- on
which a court fee of Rs. 20/- is payable. This is when the plaintiff
chooses to value the Suit for Rs. 200/- which also determines the forum
where the Suit shall be tried.

150. Section 8 of the Suits Valuation Act, 1887 provides that where a
Suit is valued at a certain amount for the purpose of jurisdiction, then the
court fee shall be also payable at the same amount.

151. Since the Suit valuation for the purpose of jurisdiction is Rs.
1,00,00,000/-, the plaintiff/ Respondent No.1 has been in error in paying
fixed court fee of Rs. 20/-.as ad valoraem fee should have been on the
sum of Rs. 1,00,00,000/-. The court fee is deficient, and the
plaintiff/respondent No. 1 is directed to make good the deficient court
fee within 1 (one) week.

152. CM APPL. 6041/2016 has been filed by the appellant in the present
appeal seeking for an exemption from paying additional Court Fees
beyond the fixed Fee of Rs. 20. Since the Suit has been valued at Rs.
1,00,00,000, by respondent No. 1, the appellant shall also be liable to
pay the deficient court in the same manner for the present appeal.

ISSUE NO. 2: -

" Whether the Suit for declaration is maintainable in its present
form? OPP"
153. A Preliminary Objection had been taken on behalf of the appellant
that the present Suit for declaration is not maintainable as consequential
relief of possession has not been sought. Since, the appellant and the
RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 60 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
respondents are in constructive joint possession of the suit property being
the joint owners and the co-owners of the suit property, the consequential
relief of possession was not required to be sought. Therefore, Suit for
Declaration on the status of being the Karta of HUF as filed by the
respondent No. 1, is maintainable simplicitor and no consequential relief
is required to be claimed.

154. Lastly, this Court appreciates the assistance provided by the Amicus
Curiae Ms. Aakanksha Kaul.

RELIEF: -

The respondent No. 1 is hereby declared as the Karta for the
purposes of representing the "D.R. Gupta & Sons HUF" before the
Competent Authority. Deficient Court fee be paid. In view of the above
discussion, we find no merit in the present appeal which is hereby
dismissed.

(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE

(SURESH KUMAR KAIT)
JUDGE

DECEMBER 04, 2023
Ek /S.Sharma

RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 61 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29
RFA(OS) 13/2016 Page 62 of 59
Signature Not Verified
DigitallySigned By:VIKAS
ARORA
Signing Date:06.12.2023
23:47:29

Related AI tags, queries and research notes

Translation





About
Disclaimer
Privacy Policy
Terms
Case Removal
Blog
Share URL



Mobile View

(function() {
const shareBtn = document.getElementById('share-url-btn');

if (navigator.share) {
shareBtn.style.display = 'inline-block';

shareBtn.addEventListener('click', async function() {
try {
await navigator.share({
title: document.title,
url: window.location.href
});
} catch (err) {
if (err.name !== 'AbortError') {
console.error('Error sharing:', err);
}
}
});
}
})();





(function($) {
function ensureAutocompleteAvailable() {
if (!($.ui && $.ui.autocomplete)) {
throw new Error('jQuery UI Autocomplete plugin not loaded');
}
}

function overrideGlobalRenderer() {
$.ui.autocomplete.prototype._renderItem = function(ul, item) {
return $("")
.append(
$("
")
.addClass("search-autocomplete-item-wrapper")
.html(item.label)
)
.appendTo(ul);
};
}

function attachAutocomplete($input) {
if (!$input.length) {
return;
}

var $form = $input.closest('form');

$input.autocomplete({
source: "/qsuggest/",
delay: 180,
minLength: 2,
appendTo: 'body',
position: {
my: "left top",
at: "left bottom+6",
collision: "flipfit"
},
classes: {
"ui-autocomplete": "search-autocomplete-list",
"ui-menu-item-wrapper": "search-autocomplete-item"
},
open: function() {
var $menu = $input.autocomplete('widget');
var offset = $input.offset();
$menu
.width($input.outerWidth())
.css({
left: offset.left,
top: offset.top + $input.outerHeight() + 6
});
$input.addClass('autocomplete-open');
},
close: function() {
$input.removeClass('autocomplete-open');
},
focus: function(event, ui) {
// Prevent the default text replacement while navigating suggestions
if (ui && ui.item) {
event.preventDefault();
}
},
select: function(event, ui) {
event.preventDefault();
if (ui && ui.item) {
$input.val(ui.item.value);
}

if ($form.length) {
$form.trigger('submit');
} else {
$('#search-form').trigger('submit');
}
}
});

}

$(document).ready(function() {
ensureAutocompleteAvailable();
overrideGlobalRenderer();
attachAutocomplete($("#search-box"));
attachAutocomplete($("#header-search-box"));
});
})(jQuery);

$(document).ready(function() {
$('#pdfdoc').button({icons: {primary: 'ui-icon-document'}});
$('#printdoc').button({icons: {primary: 'ui-icon-print'}});
$('#courtcopysubmit').button({icons: {primary: 'ui-icon-arrowthickstop-1-s'}});

$('#courtcopyform').submit(function(e) {
signupForDownload();
e.preventDefault();
return false;
});

$('#translatewarn').click(function(e) {
e.preventDefault();
var params = {title: 'Warning on translation', closeText: "", width: 450};
var content = 'The option to translate the legal documents is to overcome language barriers and for broader understanding but should not be considered as authoritative text for any official purpose.
As pointed out, translation of legal texts may be inaccurate. So beware of it when using the translate feature. Lastly, translations here are provided by Google Translate and we do not warrant its accuracy.
';
modify_dialog_params(params);
$('').html(content).dialog(params);
});
});
function googleTranslateElementInit() {
var translateElementId = 'google_translate_element';
var translateContainer = document.getElementById(translateElementId);
if (!translateContainer) {
console.warn('Google Translate container not found; skipping widget init.');
return;
}
if (typeof google === 'undefined' || !google.translate || !google.translate.TranslateElement) {
console.error('Google Translate API failed to load');
return;
}
new google.translate.TranslateElement({pageLanguage: 'en'}, translateElementId);

function removeUnwantedText() {
var translateEl = document.getElementById(translateElementId);
if (!translateEl) {
console.warn('Google Translate element became unavailable; skipping cleanup.');
return;
}

var pattern = /(translate|powered\s+by)/gi;
var hideStyle = 'display:none;visibility:hidden;width:0;height:0;padding:0;margin:0';

var walker = document.createTreeWalker(translateEl, NodeFilter.SHOW_TEXT, null, false);
var node;
while (node = walker.nextNode()) {
if (pattern.test(node.textContent)) {
node.textContent = node.textContent.replace(pattern, '').replace(/\s+/g, ' ').trim();
}
}

translateEl.querySelectorAll('*').forEach(function(el) {
if (el.querySelector('select') || el.querySelector('img')) return;
var text = el.textContent || '';
if (pattern.test(text) && text.trim()) {
el.textContent = text.replace(pattern, '').trim();
if (!el.textContent.trim()) {
el.style.cssText = hideStyle;
}
}
});
}

setTimeout(removeUnwantedText, 200);
}

$(document).ready(function () {
$('#translatewarn').button({icons: {primary: 'ui-icon-info'}, text: false});
$('.searchbox_top a').button();
$('#casemonitor').button({icon: 'ui-icon-alert'}).click({
valid_ag: '',
is_valid: '',
is_auth: 'False',
is_agreement: '',
headline: 'judgments that cite this document. Query alert for'
}, registerEmailAlert);
});

#case-recast-fab {
position: fixed;
bottom: 148px;
right: 20px;
/* Must stay under mini-chatbot.css's --z-widget (1000) so the open
chat panel covers this button instead of it punching through. */
z-index: 999;
background: transparent;
border: none;
cursor: pointer;
padding: 0;
text-decoration: none;
}

#case-recast-fab .crf-icon-wrapper {
display: flex;
flex-direction: column;
align-items: center;
gap: 4px;
padding: 8px;
border-radius: 12px;
background: rgba(255, 255, 255, 0.1);
transition: all 0.3s ease;
}

#case-recast-fab .crf-icon {
display: flex;
align-items: center;
justify-content: center;
width: 80px;
height: 80px;
font-size: 56px;
line-height: 1;
color: var(--primary-color, #1a4789);
filter: drop-shadow(0 4px 12px rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.2));
transition: all 0.3s ease;
}

#case-recast-fab .crf-label {
font-size: 10px;
font-weight: 700;
color: var(--dark-color, #1e293b);
text-transform: uppercase;
margin-top: 2px;
background: #ffffff;
padding: 2px 6px;
border-radius: 4px;
}

#case-recast-fab:focus-visible {
outline: 2px solid var(--accent-color, #4db0e1);
outline-offset: 4px;
border-radius: 12px;
}

#case-recast-fab:hover .crf-icon-wrapper {
background: rgba(255, 255, 255, 0.2);
transform: translateY(-2px);
}

#case-recast-fab:hover .crf-icon {
transform: translateY(-3px) scale(1.06);
filter: drop-shadow(0 4px 10px rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.15));
}

#case-recast-fab:hover .crf-label {
color: var(--accent-color, #4db0e1);
text-decoration: none;
}


⚖
Case Recast AI

// Authentication context for chatbot
window.is_auth = false;

// Document context for chatbot
window.documentContext = {
tid: 44799346,
title: "Manu Gupta vs Sujata Sharma & Ors on 4 December, 2023",
url: window.location.href,
isFragment: false
};

// Point the widget to the existing API endpoints

(function(){function c(){var b=a.contentDocument||(a.contentWindow&&a.contentWindow.document);if(b){var d=b.createElement('script');d.innerHTML="window.__CF$cv$params={r:'a4593b584836e6b7',t:'MTc5MTE2OTgxMQ=='};var a=document.createElement('script');a.src='/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/scripts/jsd/main.js';document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(a);";b.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(d)}}if(document.body){var a=document.createElement('iframe');a.height=1;a.width=1;a.style.position='absolute';a.style.top=0;a.style.left=0;a.style.border='none';a.style.visibility='hidden';document.body.appendChild(a);if('loading'!==document.readyState)c();else if(window.addEventListener)document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded',c);else{var e=document.onreadystatechange||function(){};document.onreadystatechange=function(b){e(b);'loading'!==document.readyState&&(document.onreadystatechange=e,c())}}}})();

Our Analysis

Your Married Daughter Can Own Family Property Now by Ishita Mehta · 8 April 2026